Állex Sodi Posted July 6, 2023 at 01:18 PM Posted July 6, 2023 at 01:18 PM So...Celine was groomed and she stayed married to her "groomer" for 20+ years, had kids with him, and hasn't publicly dated since he passed away? In what universe does that ever happen? For this narrative to work, those who believe it must assert that Celine is not only a victim, but was effectively brainwashed and psycho-emotionally stunted leading into and throughout her adulthood -- leading up to the present day. I don't buy it at all. Remember: Celine's family initiated the professional relationship with Rene, not the other way around. It started as business, not some creeper selecting a victim and looking to exploit a child. Well, that is exactly how grooming works. First of all, in most cases it’s about opportunity, not exactly planning. You pick up a child, a 12yo one in this case, in the midst of their neuropsychomotor development, in a fase where they’re creating concepts of social relationships, a certain level of autonomy from parents, and you groom the kid to believe you are the most important human being in their life. You interfere in their process of understanding the social interactions and manipulate the feelings involved. You do this right, chances are the child will spend the rest of his life believing that loving you is the only possible option, and that you are the center of their world. But, psychological issues aside, do you actually believe, to a point of blindly defend, that is ok to a older man to be romantically/sexually involved with someone he met as a 12yo child and watched grow? Could you feel sexually attracted to someone you met when they were a kid? It’s a honest question, because when I think about the today adults that I followed through childhood and, in someway, participated in their raising, just the thought of seeing them in a sexually manner is enough to make me sick. 3
PuraVida Posted July 6, 2023 at 01:19 PM Posted July 6, 2023 at 01:19 PM Seeing Celine and Rene in interviews and documentaries I always had the impression that there was sincere chemistry between them, especially around 1999 and in the early 2000s. They were both happy and glowing. I don’t think that you can fake such emotions. Celine really seemed fulfilled as a woman. Lots of 1990s interviews asked them about their relationship. Celine explains her love for Rene in this clip
CelinesDIVO5 Posted July 6, 2023 at 02:21 PM Posted July 6, 2023 at 02:21 PM Well, that is exactly how grooming works. First of all, in most cases it’s about opportunity, not exactly planning. You pick up a child, a 12yo one in this case, in the midst of their neuropsychomotor development, in a fase where they’re creating concepts of social relationships, a certain level of autonomy from parents, and you groom the kid to believe you are the most important human being in their life. You interfere in their process of understanding the social interactions and manipulate the feelings involved. You do this right, chances are the child will spend the rest of his life believing that loving you is the only possible option, and that you are the center of their world. But, psychological issues aside, do you actually believe, to a point of blindly defend, that is ok to a older man to be romantically/sexually involved with someone he met as a 12yo child and watched grow? Could you feel sexually attracted to someone you met when they were a kid? It’s a honest question, because when I think about the today adults that I followed through childhood and, in someway, participated in their raising, just the thought of seeing them in a sexually manner is enough to make me sick. Celine always maintained that her parents were always the most important people in her life though. Especially during those early years where her mother never left her side. 1 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PL54qnRGM2gMatthew Charles - "Fix You" - Live at The Stonewall InnStonewall Sensation - Season 15Originally written and performed by Coldplay
Chantemoi Posted July 7, 2023 at 02:40 AM Posted July 7, 2023 at 02:40 AM (edited) But, psychological issues aside, do you actually believe, to a point of blindly defend, that is ok to a older man to be romantically/sexually involved with someone he met as a 12yo child and watched grow? Could you feel sexually attracted to someone you met when they were a kid? It’s a honest question, because when I think about the today adults that I followed through childhood and, in someway, participated in their raising, just the thought of seeing them in a sexually manner is enough to make me sick. Well, your response is also psychological, and I assume there are a lot of factors at play there as well. I’m not here to blindly defend René, but I’m saying we don’t know the full story. What we do know is that Céline was obsessed with him when she was a teenager. Read the lyrics of practically any song by Eddy Marnay, and the subtext is obvious. If Eddy (and I’m sure many other adults) could see her love for him, then I’m sure that made it very uncomfortable for René to be around her. I can’t recall where I got the impression, but I seem to remember that he actively tried to distance himself from her during some point of that era and make it obvious that he was not involved with her. What we do not know is the private conversations he had with her then - was he manipulating her, in order to keep her (and the cash flow) close to home? He famously lost Ginette Reno because of her boyfriend, so it’s plausible he “played his cards right” to string her along until she was an adult. I seriously doubt he would “gamble” being caught up in a physical relationship with a minor, but it’s fairly safe to assume he’d contemplated the thought long before Eurovision. Whether or not he groomed her, or their physical relationship started in 1988, we will never know. Again, what we do know is that Céline’s devotion persevered all of her family, friends, and even the public’s perception of that relationship as something abnormal, exploitative and abusive. As an adult, she would have had plenty of opportunities to contemplate their past and decide if it was appropriate. What did she do? She doubled down and had 3 kids with him. She didn’t cheat on him (that we are aware) and she has maintained her devotion to him in the years after his death. In the past few years, when I saw her going through the Celinaissance I could not help but wonder what was going through her mind. Did she lose all that weight because she was processing their past from a new, liberated perspective? Did she confide a lot of dirt to Pepe? Is that why she “partied” a little more, to avoid facing the ugly truth? Or was it truly because she struggled to face her career and personal life without her partner, who made so many important decisions? I’m sticking with the latter until I hear otherwise… Edited July 7, 2023 at 02:44 AM by Chantemoi
incognito Posted July 7, 2023 at 04:20 AM Posted July 7, 2023 at 04:20 AM Well, your response is also psychological, and I assume there are a lot of factors at play there as well. I’m not here to blindly defend René, but I’m saying we don’t know the full story. What we do know is that Céline was obsessed with him when she was a teenager. Read the lyrics of practically any song by Eddy Marnay, and the subtext is obvious. If Eddy (and I’m sure many other adults) could see her love for him, then I’m sure that made it very uncomfortable for René to be around her. I can’t recall where I got the impression, but I seem to remember that he actively tried to distance himself from her during some point of that era and make it obvious that he was not involved with her. What we do not know is the private conversations he had with her then - was he manipulating her, in order to keep her (and the cash flow) close to home? He famously lost Ginette Reno because of her boyfriend, so it’s plausible he “played his cards right” to string her along until she was an adult. I seriously doubt he would “gamble” being caught up in a physical relationship with a minor, but it’s fairly safe to assume he’d contemplated the thought long before Eurovision. Whether or not he groomed her, or their physical relationship started in 1988, we will never know. Again, what we do know is that Céline’s devotion persevered all of her family, friends, and even the public’s perception of that relationship as something abnormal, exploitative and abusive. As an adult, she would have had plenty of opportunities to contemplate their past and decide if it was appropriate. What did she do? She doubled down and had 3 kids with him. She didn’t cheat on him (that we are aware) and she has maintained her devotion to him in the years after his death. In the past few years, when I saw her going through the Celinaissance I could not help but wonder what was going through her mind. Did she lose all that weight because she was processing their past from a new, liberated perspective? Did she confide a lot of dirt to Pepe? Is that why she “partied” a little more, to avoid facing the ugly truth? Or was it truly because she struggled to face her career and personal life without her partner, who made so many important decisions? I’m sticking with the latter until I hear otherwise… Yes. We just don’t know. I mean, just because Rene’s best friend - Guy Cloutier - was a convicted pedophile who groomed and abused his child client in the early 1980s, it doesn’t mean that Rene was too.
PuraVida Posted July 7, 2023 at 04:57 AM Posted July 7, 2023 at 04:57 AM But, psychological issues aside, do you actually believe, to a point of blindly defend, that is ok to a older man to be romantically/sexually involved with someone he met as a 12yo child and watched grow? Could you feel sexually attracted to someone you met when they were a kid? It's a honest question, because when I think about the today adults that I followed through childhood and, in someway, participated in their raising, just the thought of seeing them in a sexually manner is enough to make me sick. I don't blindly defend anything. And, unlike many other fans, I don't have any particular sentimentality for their relationship. Never did. But I don't think the facts point to grooming in the least. I am very happy that people are skeptical and questioning regarding this matter. It's right to be. Thankfully, over the years movements like Me Too have further awakened public consciousness. But when I compare definitions and accounts of grooming, and compare that to Celine's life and her time with Rene...I don't see it. You can find their relationship weird, icky, unhealthy, co-dependent, etc. for whatever reason, but that is not the same thing as "Rene Angelil groomed Celine Dion." 3
CourageProject Posted July 7, 2023 at 05:05 AM Posted July 7, 2023 at 05:05 AM Yes. We just don’t know. I mean, just because Rene’s best friend - Guy Cloutier - was a convicted pedophile who groomed and abused his child client in the early 1980s, it doesn’t mean that Rene was too.I didn't know that
comingback Posted July 7, 2023 at 08:07 AM Posted July 7, 2023 at 08:07 AM (edited) Well, your response is also psychological, and I assume there are a lot of factors at play there as well. I'm not here to blindly defend René, but I'm saying we don't know the full story. What we do know is that Céline was obsessed with him when she was a teenager. Read the lyrics of practically any song by Eddy Marnay, and the subtext is obvious. If Eddy (and I'm sure many other adults) could see her love for him, then I'm sure that made it very uncomfortable for René to be around her. I can't recall where I got the impression, but I seem to remember that he actively tried to distance himself from her during some point of that era and make it obvious that he was not involved with her. What we do not know is the private conversations he had with her then - was he manipulating her, in order to keep her (and the cash flow) close to home? He famously lost Ginette Reno because of her boyfriend, so it's plausible he "played his cards right" to string her along until she was an adult. I seriously doubt he would "gamble" being caught up in a physical relationship with a minor, but it's fairly safe to assume he'd contemplated the thought long before Eurovision. Whether or not he groomed her, or their physical relationship started in 1988, we will never know. Again, what we do know is that Céline's devotion persevered all of her family, friends, and even the public's perception of that relationship as something abnormal, exploitative and abusive. As an adult, she would have had plenty of opportunities to contemplate their past and decide if it was appropriate. What did she do? She doubled down and had 3 kids with him. She didn't cheat on him (that we are aware) and she has maintained her devotion to him in the years after his death. In the past few years, when I saw her going through the Celinaissance I could not help but wonder what was going through her mind. Did she lose all that weight because she was processing their past from a new, liberated perspective? Did she confide a lot of dirt to Pepe? Is that why she "partied" a little more, to avoid facing the ugly truth? Or was it truly because she struggled to face her career and personal life without her partner, who made so many important decisions? I'm sticking with the latter until I hear otherwise… https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EnLE2Y4oNVo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gAzkthiMRJE Yes, I also remember him saying that he distanced himself from her during that time. But we don't know what happened in private life/behind the scenes. I really hope he hasn't manipulated her or sth. like that. But the album C'est Pour Toi from 1985 is clearly about her love for Rene. And yes, the Eurovision date has always been weird. But we don't know... Edited July 7, 2023 at 08:17 AM by comingback
PuraVida Posted July 7, 2023 at 08:53 AM Posted July 7, 2023 at 08:53 AM Celine's family was always by her side, namely her mother. No reports that Rene ever tried to isolate Celine, hard to imagine anyone in her large family could have overlooked such behaviour. Nevertheless, the speculation about things that could have happened in private will continue to power this rumour mill for many more years. Heck, it even gave Aline's mother a heart attack in the film.
comingback Posted July 7, 2023 at 10:26 AM Posted July 7, 2023 at 10:26 AM (edited) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EnLE2Y4oNVo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gAzkthiMRJE Yes, I also remember him saying that he distanced himself from her during that time. But we don't know what happened in private life/behind the scenes. I really hope he didn't manipulate her or sth. like that. The album C'est Pour Toi from 1985 is clearly about her love for Rene. And yes, the Eurovision date has always been weird. But we don't know... Edited July 7, 2023 at 10:33 AM by comingback
comingback Posted July 7, 2023 at 12:02 PM Posted July 7, 2023 at 12:02 PM I don't blindly defend anything. And, unlike many other fans, I don't have any particular sentimentality for their relationship. Never did. But I don't think the facts point to grooming in the least. I am very happy that people are skeptical and questioning regarding this matter. It's right to be. Thankfully, over the years movements like Me Too have further awakened public consciousness. But when I compare definitions and accounts of grooming, and compare that to Celine's life and her time with Rene...I don't see it. You can find their relationship weird, icky, unhealthy, co-dependent, etc. for whatever reason, but that is not the same thing as "Rene Angelil groomed Celine Dion." And that's the point. Maybe their relationship was weird and unhealthy, but until we hear sth. new, it was legal. 2
scielle Posted July 7, 2023 at 04:40 PM Posted July 7, 2023 at 04:40 PM How long do we give Team Céline to get her on Threads? 😜More places to sell cheap MHWGO keychains! 1
CourageProject Posted July 7, 2023 at 05:45 PM Posted July 7, 2023 at 05:45 PM How long do we give Team Céline to get her on Threads? 😜More places to sell cheap MHWGO keychains!Only cool people join, they can't even handle twitter regularly 🤣
PuraVida Posted July 7, 2023 at 05:49 PM Posted July 7, 2023 at 05:49 PM And that's the point. Maybe their relationship was weird and unhealthy, but until we hear sth. new, it was legal. And hear something from Celine herself especially. She's not dumb -- there were interviews where she mentioned she knew that people might be under the misconception that he was taking advantage. I am sure she would clear up these things in an interview...except of course it's very uncouth to ask now that's he's gone. But there are old interviews where she has talked about it, although without the term "grooming" attached or explained. 1
maki_Dion-er Posted July 7, 2023 at 11:08 PM Posted July 7, 2023 at 11:08 PM People that are groomed or conditioned by others will always defend their partners, always say there's nothing wrong (especially in front of a camera as Celine has done about his gambling. Celine, the same person who doesn't like gambling is gonna be okay w/ him gambling away millions? Sure) because they are in love with said person. Grooming and being in love are not mutually exclusive, and as long as the person is in love why wouldn't they stay in the relationship.Besides, Celine's actions or feelings aren't the issue (she's the pressumed victim), it's his. Rene was mad when Celine showed interest in two different young men close to her age and made sure she didn't date out of fear that he'd lose his star like what happened with Ginette Reno, that's so wrong, totally controlling (from a man that claimed to not be controlling). Celine's admited in the past that she didn't carry a cellphone, wallet, didn't know her bank passcode, and didn't even know how to check in to a hotel. Always told to just focus on her singing and not worry about anything else. This is textbook on creating dependency on him (whether done consciously or subconsciously). And it doesn't matter if Celine was an emotionally mature girl, she was still a young girl that was highly protected, with no life experience that was following her heart. As an example, she didn't like school so her mom & Rene let her quit (meanwhile, Paul, her first manager, insisted that she get an education & live the life of a normal teen) years later she expressed regret at not finishing. It's impossible to accuse him of grooming (with solid proof) at this point, but it's careless to try to defend him imo because groomer or not he did plenty wrong. Doesn’t matter if it's "legal", plenty of things can be legal but not right imo. Also important to note that a person can be groomed at any age, same for any type of manipulation. And even if he's gone now, these are conversations that I think are important to have. 6
Zofia Posted July 8, 2023 at 01:08 AM Posted July 8, 2023 at 01:08 AM People that are groomed or conditioned by others will always defend their partners, always say there's nothing wrong (especially in front of a camera as Celine has done about his gambling. Celine, the same person who doesn't like gambling is gonna be okay w/ him gambling away millions? Sure) because they are in love with said person. Grooming and being in love are not mutually exclusive, and as long as the person is in love why wouldn't they stay in the relationship.Besides, Celine's actions or feelings aren't the issue (she's the pressumed victim), it's his. Rene was mad when Celine showed interest in two different young men close to her age and made sure she didn't date out of fear that he'd lose his star like what happened with Ginette Reno, that's so wrong, totally controlling (from a man that claimed to not be controlling). Celine's admited in the past that she didn't carry a cellphone, wallet, didn't know her bank passcode, and didn't even know how to check in to a hotel. Always told to just focus on her singing and not worry about anything else. This is textbook on creating dependency on him (whether done consciously or subconsciously). And it doesn't matter if Celine was an emotionally mature girl, she was still a young girl that was highly protected, with no life experience that was following her heart. As an example, she didn't like school so her mom & Rene let her quit (meanwhile, Paul, her first manager, insisted that she get an education & live the life of a normal teen) years later she expressed regret at not finishing. It's impossible to accuse him of grooming (with solid proof) at this point, but it's careless to try to defend him imo because groomer or not he did plenty wrong. Doesn't matter if it's "legal", plenty of things can be legal but not right imo. Also important to note that a person can be groomed at any age, same for any type of manipulation. And even if he's gone now, these are conversations that I think are important to have. I couldn't agree more. First of all, arguments that refer to what Céline herself said (or didn't say) are perfectly reversible, because the deeper the manipulation, the less conscious (even if intelligent) the person being manipulated is, and this is even essential in this type of abuse. This is not, of course, proof of abuse, but it does invalidate arguments such as "she disputes it herself", "she hasn't admitted it herself", and so on. Secondly, we necessarily refer to what public figures say or do in the public arena, without knowing much about their private lives, which gives us far too limited a framework to "diagnose" anything. Yet thirdly, the type of stories to which this legend can be used as an alibi ("an under-age girl who seduced a man twice her age", "she's the one responsible", etc.) seems really unhealthy. Finally, as maki_Dion-er said, even if grooming remains difficult/impossible to prove, the themes of control and dependency alone are very worrying. When I think of Céline's fate after 2016, the image comes to mind of an extremely brave soldier who is also somehow unarmed (or at least one who hasn't undergone military training). What happens to a courageous, disarmed soldier when real combat breaks out?... And yes, I can't get my head around the idea of taking a 12-year-old out of school ("because she hates it") and putting her to work in the music industry ("because she dreams about it")... Some childhood dreams are best summed up as « ce n’était qu’un rêve », rather than realized at all costs. The Paul Lévesque team... But that's another story. 3
CourageProject Posted July 8, 2023 at 02:05 AM Posted July 8, 2023 at 02:05 AM Their whole relationship is a bit creepy at first, an older man falling for a minor. As she got older, it doesn't bother that much but imagine it when she was 12, 13.
RosieBarron Posted July 8, 2023 at 06:01 AM Posted July 8, 2023 at 06:01 AM I've followed Celine for a very long time and watched thousands of interviews, read all the books etc. Some of the 'facts' being quoted in this thread to prove Rene's guilt I have never heard before. Even some of the things Celine is alleged to have said herself. Will just leave that there. 1
comingback Posted July 8, 2023 at 09:42 AM Posted July 8, 2023 at 09:42 AM (edited) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sO966zLTtmo very interesting docu about Rene Yes, he was a great manager, because he controlled and managed everything in her career. We can't judge how far his control compulsion went, but we know Celine just needed to focus on singing.... But when you look at the relationship between Mariah Carey and Tommy Mottola, raises the question of Rene's need of control. Mariah and Mottola divorced in 1997 and even today Mariah has mental health problems. Edited July 8, 2023 at 10:02 AM by comingback
Shaun Posted July 8, 2023 at 10:22 AM Posted July 8, 2023 at 10:22 AM I'm genuinely astonished at what I'm seeing here. I'd expect the contempt and suspicion regarding their relationship from the tabloid media and the general public / haters but from Celine's own devoted and longtime fans? Particularly more than 6 years after Rene's death! Astonishing. 6 Bringing you the world's only Celine Dion podcast show since 2014.Find us on Soundcloud, Apple Podcasts, Spotify & Amazon Music.
RosieBarron Posted July 8, 2023 at 10:26 AM Posted July 8, 2023 at 10:26 AM (edited) I'm genuinely astonished at what I'm seeing here. I'd expect the contempt and suspicion regarding their relationship from the tabloid media and the general public / haters but from Celine's own devoted and longtime fans? Particularly more than 6 years after Rene's death! Astonishing. 100% agree. I can only imagine how hurtful some of the things being posted in this thread would be if she were to see them. Edited July 8, 2023 at 10:28 AM by RosieBarron
comingback Posted July 8, 2023 at 11:11 AM Posted July 8, 2023 at 11:11 AM (edited) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sO966zLTtmo very interesting docu about Rene Yes, he was a great manager, because he controlled and managed everything in her career. We can't judge how far his control compulsion went, but we know Celine just needed to focus on singing.... But when you look at the relationship between Mariah Carey and Tommy Mottola, it raises the question of Rene's need of control. Mariah and Mottola got divorced in 1997 and even today Mariah has mental health problems. Edited July 8, 2023 at 11:17 AM by comingback
zuv Posted July 8, 2023 at 12:22 PM Posted July 8, 2023 at 12:22 PM Listening to Adele this morning. I feel like i’m cheating 😓
Davey84 Posted July 8, 2023 at 03:18 PM Posted July 8, 2023 at 03:18 PM Listening to Adele this morning. I feel like im cheating Cheating with good taste? Verstuurd vanaf mijn SM-G781B met Tapatalk http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v75/daveyh84/incognito198701_zpsaaootxh1.jpgRick, ik hou van jou voor altijd!A New Day... has come 28/29 April & 2/3 May 07Antwerpen 13 et 14 mai,Paris 24 et 25 mai, Amsterdam 2 juinet Arras 7 juillet Chances Taken!!!How Do You Keep The Music Playing? - Celine Opening Night March 15th, March 16th
Chantemoi Posted July 8, 2023 at 03:50 PM Posted July 8, 2023 at 03:50 PM (edited) I'm genuinely astonished at what I'm seeing here. I'd expect the contempt and suspicion regarding their relationship from the tabloid media and the general public / haters but from Celine's own devoted and longtime fans? Particularly more than 6 years after Rene's death! Astonishing. 100% agree. I can only imagine how hurtful some of the things being posted in this thread would be if she were to see them. Some fans aren't able to "go there." They don't want to participate in such frank discussions that even hint at questioning the "fairy tale" romance of Céline & René... but clearly, there are some of us who aren't able to ignore it either. We can't "separate the artist from the art" because they didn't have the sense to do that themselves - especially in her early Marnay-penned recordings, many of which contain strong lyrical references* to an older man in her life. Are we to ignore that she not only recorded a song titled "LOLITA" but also released it as a single? In case anyone was unaware, the song title references the novel (and subsequent movie) about a child who has a sexual relationship with a man - a man who was so attracted to her, that he married the girl's mother just to have an excuse to be near the child... and yet the narrative implies the child was the one who seduced a poor old, innocent man. I don't know how any person - let alone a fan - could brush aside the implications of such explosive lyrics written by Luc Plamondon, sung by Céline, and ultimately released by René. Whether or not they were meant to be taken literally, it was a dangerous move from a PR perspective, and it's it makes easy fodder for people who want to believe René purposely took advantage of her. * I invite everyone who is intrigued by this topic to take a closer look at her lyrics, in chronological order, because if you read between the lines, I think it suggests a plausible, mostly innocent narrative: Le vieux Monsieur de la rue Royale (age 14) - https://www.celinedi...-la-rue-royale/Just your everyday song about a girl idolizing an old man to the point of seeing him in the clouds as a young man that she vows to love "simply, truly and forever". While I always believed Eddy wrote it about himself, it is still a little creepy. How many young girls do you know who would sing this song about a man other than a grandfather? Les chemins de ma maison album (age 15) - https://www.celinedi...s-de-ma-maison/At age 15, this album is completely wholesome, but Eddy Marnay declares in the liner notes:"This album, Céline, is precious. It is the last impression which you will leave for us of your childhood. Later, it's your life of a woman which you will sing for us. May it steep in the same music and the same light. - Eddy Marnay" Trois heures vingt (age 16) - https://www.celinedi...s-heures-vingt/Just an average song about a teen who knows she's "too young" for a man, yet wants to leave her parents and runaway to be with him. The tone in this one is strong: there is unquestionable obedience to follow his plan, yet a palpable sense of guilt. The song René chose for his funeral, and Céline used to open the summer tour of 2016. Trop jeune à dix-sept ans (Too Young at Seventeen Years Old) (age 16)- https://www.celinedi...a-dix-sept-ans/The title says it all. Un amour pour moi (Age 16) - https://www.celinedi...amour-pour-moi/"I write my story at the turn of his hand/ He writes his story at the turn of my heart/ And if he wants to wait for me at the turn of the path/ I will meet him at the turn of happiness..." Dis-moi si je t'aime (Tell Me If I'm in Love with You) (age 17) - https://www.celinedi...oi-si-je-taime/Just an average song about a girl shutting herself off from the world in isolation because the object of her affections isn't returning the "call" so to speak. If we take this literally, it suggests that René was distancing himself from her, as his own accounts have claimed. Whether or not intentional, it does imply that Céline's obsession was deeply rooted at this point in her life. It wasn't something to shrug off. Avec Toi (age 17) - https://www.celinedi...yrics/avec-toi/Just an average song about a teen girl losing her mind while waiting to share her bed, to "devour the best fruits" and give her virginity to a man who is "pure amongst the wolves". By far the more lustful song she had recorded to date. Lolita (Too Young for Love) - https://www.celinedi...une-pour-aimer/" 'I sang for the first time the lyrics from Lolita in front of Rene,' Céline tells, 'to provoke him. I wasn't looking at him, but I was sure that he hanging on every word and that he was upset... It was strange, a kind of declaration of chaste and unchaste love. Then we kept silent for a long while. The message was direct.' " There is plenty of reason for suspicion in the lyrics above. None of these songs can be taken as Céline lusting after a boy her own age - because we also know she hardly had any friends her own age. And yes, René did discourage her from dating other boys. It is documented in her biographies. Aside from her nieces and nephews, she was constantly surrounded by adults so she was a very rare example of a teen living in a much more mature world than her contemporaries. Again, if the songs provide any clues, we can see Céline was obsessed but the relationship with René was still unconsummated at age 19. There is no proof or reason to suspect any nefarious physical relationship occurred while she was a minor. But the recent discussion in this forum has been whether or not her obsession was guided and encouraged - directly or indirectly - which is categorically called "grooming." As long as we continue to keep the discussion free of judgment of René (who is no longer able to defend himself), I don't see how that makes us "contemptuous" or any less of fans than those to choose to look away. Edited July 8, 2023 at 04:00 PM by Chantemoi 7
Shaun Posted July 8, 2023 at 04:32 PM Posted July 8, 2023 at 04:32 PM Or they could just, ya know, be song lyrics. I don’t actually believe Celine drove all night to creep into someone’s room you know. 2 Bringing you the world's only Celine Dion podcast show since 2014.Find us on Soundcloud, Apple Podcasts, Spotify & Amazon Music.
comingback Posted July 8, 2023 at 04:53 PM Posted July 8, 2023 at 04:53 PM (edited) Come on, the song Lolita and the songs from Marnay are very clear, Rene was the topic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W4H4KibeEEM Edited July 8, 2023 at 05:05 PM by comingback
RosieBarron Posted July 8, 2023 at 06:23 PM Posted July 8, 2023 at 06:23 PM Come on, the song Lolita and the songs from Marnay are very clear, Rene was the topic https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W4H4KibeEEM Yes but she was like 19 then. This topic is just getting ridiculous. Let's just go with Celine's own interpretation of her own life. She clearly loved Rene and misses him. If she ever decides to change that narrative then we'll worry about it then. I very much doubt that will happen as not in anyway does she give of the impression of thinking she has been mistreated. Saying things like oh the victim protects the abuser etc is so unhelpful. If she is happy with how things played out then just leave it, she knows better than any of us ever will what happened. 1
Shaun Posted July 8, 2023 at 08:04 PM Posted July 8, 2023 at 08:04 PM This topic is just getting ridiculous. Correct. Bringing you the world's only Celine Dion podcast show since 2014.Find us on Soundcloud, Apple Podcasts, Spotify & Amazon Music.
Peppercorn1991 Posted July 8, 2023 at 08:16 PM Posted July 8, 2023 at 08:16 PM I’ve been waiting to talk about this. I love Rene… I did and I still do. I think he was an amazing manager and husband, taking fully into account Celine’s interpretation as I grew up. As time has moved on, it is now unacceptable for a man of Renes age to be with a teen in the public eye. It does happen but more and more there is controversy surrounding such relationships. Here in the U.K. a famous presenter (Phillip Schofield) has just lost everything for being with a younger male in their teens and actually didn’t break any law (as we know of). The news was focussed on this as a main story for weeks. Celine has been brought up in the U.K. conversation too as a comparison and it really made me think more about it too. Maybe this is why people are starting to have this conversation now? We know even at the time the public found it odd and there was speculation. ‘Everybody’s talking my baby down’ comes to mind. As a fan of Celine i see how much Rene did for Celine and how they were the perfect team. I also remember as a child thinking Rene was really old as her husband but overtime I just went with it for what it was. Celine was very happy and so was I. When I became a hardcore fan, Celine was already talking about babies and having a family, so in many ways her relationship with Rene was a given without much more thought. I was devastated when Rene died as I knew how much he meant to Celine and I loved his interviews and full passion for her career. I still miss Rene a lot actually and ask myself what he would think of her latest project after each release. He was the bones of her very successful career. I truly believe it was love and there was nothing underhand. They grew together through their successful accomplishments and common aim. I certainly don’t think Rene took the opportunity to work with Celine to groom her. Weirdly though, his role was to groom her into a pop superstar…. I can understand why the subject is discussed and don’t think fans should be scared to approach it. It certainly would not be accepted in todays age and I think we can all agree on this. Celine and Rene stood the test of time and created a fairy tale all of their own. This can’t be a bad thing can it? However, the conflict is still in my mind. Kev x 2
Recommended Posts