Jump to content

Random news, thoughts and common questions about Celine (closed)


Recommended Posts

Posted

Barnev explains himself on the Quebec show “Sucré sale”:

  • Do you think we'll be seeing her again soon?
  • I don't know if we'll see her again. I hope we will. But I know she's doing better. She sent us a note saying she's doing better. I think the most important thing is her health.
  • Absolutely.
  • And when she comes back, she's going to come back at 100% and then it's going to kick #ss.

source: https://www.facebook...517765557142103

 

 

"Doing better" is very vague and relative, but nontheless it's positive. I am surprised anything at all is coming out, but I suppose Barnev wouldn't speak unless Celine gave her approval.

  • Like 3
Posted

"Doing better" is very vague and relative, but nontheless it's positive. I am surprised anything at all is coming out, but I suppose Barnev wouldn't speak unless Celine gave her approval.

 

Is she still the boss, still in control of the situation? or has this power been delegated to someone else, as is often the case with leaders who have fallen seriously ill? we don't know.

 

Of course, "better" is the word we're all waiting for. The problem is that in communication with the patient - especially if he's motivated and doesn't like to complain - "better" is very often relative ("better than yesterday", "better than last night"), whereas he's sometimes in an "equal" or "worse" state in the general sense of the word. Imagine the patient's well-being not as a straight line, but as a sinusoid: it can go up, trace a horizontal line or even go down; in all three cases, there will be moments when "he's really better".

 

All this is to say that we don't know much about the situation; to hope doesn't mean to delude ourselves on the basis of weak premises. And yet, let's continue to be very, very hopeful...

Posted
Maybe the phrase she is doing better just means exactly that, she is doing better. No need to keep trying to read more into it.
  • Like 2
Posted
Some fans can't just take the good news.
  • Like 2
Posted
I believe that our wishes and desires are identical, yet our experiences and perception of reality may be different. Let's accept that.
Posted
I don’t think a former employee of hers is going to go out on the promo circuit selling his new album by saying, “I have no idea how she’s actually doing.” He’s going to say something in vague and hopeful. “Better” is indeed a relative word, and could easily just be meant like “now that she’s seeing doctors, she’s getting better.” That protects his best interests without making a big deal about something he either knows nothing about or that they are trying to keep hush-hush.
Posted

Maybe the phrase she is doing better just means exactly that, she is doing better. No need to keep trying to read more into it.

 

Exactement!

  • Like 1
Posted

Is she still the boss, still in control of the situation? or has this power been delegated to someone else, as is often the case with leaders who have fallen seriously ill? we don't know.

 

Of course, "better" is the word we're all waiting for. The problem is that in communication with the patient - especially if he's motivated and doesn't like to complain - "better" is very often relative ("better than yesterday", "better than last night"), whereas he's sometimes in an "equal" or "worse" state in the general sense of the word. Imagine the patient's well-being not as a straight line, but as a sinusoid: it can go up, trace a horizontal line or even go down; in all three cases, there will be moments when "he's really better".

 

All this is to say that we don't know much about the situation; to hope doesn't mean to delude ourselves on the basis of weak premises. And yet, let's continue to be very, very hopeful...

 

Well, I think whoever power would be delegated to would still give a quick chat to Celine about Barnev. Would only take a few seconds to clear up whatever her wishes are. Barnev in that same interview said "he never plays the Celine card" i.e. uses his connections for favours/reputation etc.... so I don't think he would ever go against Celine's wishes. But of course we are all liable to errors in judgement.

 

Yes, I agree, like I said "better" is very relative. It reminds me of that one video message where she said "I'm doing a little bit better" ... I think that was the video before the official diagnosis video? I lost track.

  • Like 1
Posted

 

Well, I think whoever power would be delegated to would still give a quick chat to Celine about Barnev. Would only take a few seconds to clear up whatever her wishes are. Barnev in that same interview said "he never plays the Celine card" i.e. uses his connections for favours/reputation etc.... so I don't think he would ever go against Celine's wishes. But of course we are all liable to errors in judgement.

 

Yes, I agree, like I said "better" is very relative. It reminds me of that one video message where she said "I'm doing a little bit better" ... I think that was the video before the official diagnosis video? I lost track.

That video is from April of last year.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

post-37212-0-18369100-1559095633_thumb.jpg
Posted

That video is from April of last year.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

Oh...so his JDM comments haven't been echoed anywhere else yet?

Posted

Well, I think whoever power would be delegated to would still give a quick chat to Celine about Barnev. Would only take a few seconds to clear up whatever her wishes are. Barnev in that same interview said "he never plays the Celine card" i.e. uses his connections for favours/reputation etc.... so I don't think he would ever go against Celine's wishes. But of course we are all liable to errors in judgement.

 

It seems that with this declaration of "never playing the Céline card", he's trying to demonstrate his autonomy, wanting to be seen as someone who stands on his own two feet as he promotes his solo album. Nor does he claim to be part of her inner circle; according to him, after rehearsals were interrupted, he knew nothing of her illness, and only finally learned of it with the rest of the world, on December 8.

 

Yes, I agree, like I said "better" is very relative. It reminds me of that one video message where she said "I'm doing a little bit better" ... I think that was the video before the official diagnosis video? I lost track.

 

Yes, that was the message of April 29, 2022, as usual full of hope: “The good news is that I'm doing a little bit better, but it's going very slow. And it's very frustrating for me. You know, I'm getting treatment from my doctors, taking medication, but I'm still experiencing some spasm. And it's taking a lot longer for me to recover than I had hoped. I need to be in top shape when I'm on stage. I honestly can't wait, but I'm just not there yet.”

Indeed, Céline will always say that she's "getting better", it's simply her way of operating, of facing challenges; to each his own... When she's not getting better, she says nothing about it (“it’s been really difficult for me /…/ to talk about everything that I’ve been going through”, 8.12.) - which is why, at least since 2021, silence is never a good omen.

Posted

Nor does he claim to be part of her inner circle; according to him, after rehearsals were interrupted, he knew nothing of her illness, and only finally learned of it with the rest of the world, on December 8.

 

Did he say that in the Sucre Sale interview? Sorry, I didn't see the whole thing. And btw @Celinefan2019, I was referring to Barnev's "Sucre Sale" interview ... not the April 2022 message from Celine.

 

But yeah -- what does it say about Celine that her background singer of 20+ years is not in her inner circle? Then again, as I've said before on the forum, everyone handles illness and strife differently -- and Celine has every right to handle things as she sees fit. It must have been so tough. And the Quebec media world is small.

 

But yeah, I feel like in each case the "getting better" both from Celine and Barnev is probably true -- some progress, but very incremental. Essentially, her condition is more stable and the symptoms are being treated but...well, there is no cure yet. Just my speculation. I hope she is responding well to treatments.

Posted

Did he say that in the Sucre Sale interview? Sorry, I didn't see the whole thing.

 

No, he was recounting these circumstances in the JdM interview. In both cases, he doesn't claim to "know" much.

 

But yeah -- what does it say about Celine that her background singer of 20+ years is not in her inner circle? Then again, as I've said before on the forum, everyone handles illness and strife differently -- and Celine has every right to handle things as she sees fit. It must have been so tough. And the Quebec media world is small.

 

According to several testimonials (with Denise Bombardier's book in mind) Céline's closest circle was very small, and she herself, despite her warm, caring demeanor, seemed to be quite suspicious of people. I sometimes wonder: working since the age of 12, always surrounded by people older than her and with bad experiences at school, did she simply have the time and inclination to learn how to practice friendship? On the other hand, the fact that she's so used to isolating herself, paradoxically, may help her in the present situation. This disease isolates people even more than other disabling illnesses: for those who function actively, go out a lot and are very sociable, the loss of their way of life is often very destructive.

 

But yeah, I feel like in each case the "getting better" both from Celine and Barnev is probably true -- some progress, but very incremental. Essentially, her condition is more stable and the symptoms are being treated but...well, there is no cure yet. Just my speculation. I hope she is responding well to treatments.

 

Since December, I've been immersed in the world of patients with SPS, and I have to admit that in most cases it's not very encouraging. A striking feature of this disease, due to the fact that so little is known about it, is its unpredictability, in both the long and short term: from day to day, a treatment that was working well can suddenly stop working. Fortunately, the opposite situation can also occur. Unfortunately, this does not make it any easier for patients to establish a life routine, which is so useful in a chronic illness. The feeling of perpetual insecurity must be particularly uncomfortable. We can only hope that Céline manages as well as possible. And that, in time, her name will mark a new era in the treatment of this disease. And that she gets the chance to enjoy it for herself...

  • Like 1
Posted
Very Random, but why does this forum still shows the Exclusive Seats Available Vegas Shows pictures up there.
Posted

Very Random, but why does this forum still shows the Exclusive Seats Available Vegas Shows pictures up there.

 

Agreed. I wonder this also.

 

Kev x

Posted

Since December, I've been immersed in the world of patients with SPS, and I have to admit that in most cases it's not very encouraging. A striking feature of this disease, due to the fact that so little is known about it, is its unpredictability, in both the long and short term: from day to day, a treatment that was working well can suddenly stop working. Fortunately, the opposite situation can also occur. Unfortunately, this does not make it any easier for patients to establish a life routine, which is so useful in a chronic illness. The feeling of perpetual insecurity must be particularly uncomfortable. We can only hope that Céline manages as well as possible. And that, in time, her name will mark a new era in the treatment of this disease. And that she gets the chance to enjoy it for herself...

 

Yes, every so often I come across a new video from someone with her same diagnosis. And it seems wretched...but then as the video goes on, usually there is the hopeful part where they talk about how treatment has helped them get back closer to "normalcy". For example, one woman I saw said now things are more under control with her meds and she can "feel" when an flare-ups are on their way and prepare for them.

  • Like 1
Posted

Yes, every so often I come across a new video from someone with her same diagnosis. And it seems wretched...but then as the video goes on, usually there is the hopeful part where they talk about how treatment has helped them get back closer to "normalcy". For example, one woman I saw said now things are more under control with her meds and she can "feel" when an flare-ups are on their way and prepare for them.

 

Exactly, in many (most?) cases, fortunately, the disease eventually stabilizes and symptoms are brought under control - even if this usually takes years and, from the patient's point of view, often looks like a real obstacle course. It's true that most of the reports are rather edifying: on the one hand, the official media don't just want to frighten, they also want to give hope. On the other hand, the patients who decide to share their stories are essentially those who have already regained control of their lives... Like Lahoma, for example, the "Naples woman", heroine of the report which, thanks to Céline's name in the title, has already accumulated over two million views on YT: (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tC54_OvUZIE)

 

To find out more about the daily lives of people with SPS, I consult a few social media profiles and have joined the https://www.facebook.com/groups/StiffPersonSyndrome support group. Here, the information is less elaborate than in news reports, it's raw and spontaneous, written day by day, sometimes full of good news, sometimes full of despair. You can follow someone's story without knowing what happens next. I learn a lot from it. For the moment, it's the only way I can indirectly accompany Céline in what she is going through - and thanks to her, to listen to people the world didn't hear before December 8...

  • Like 1
Posted
It makes me so angry how they dismissed that woman's symptoms as being "in her head" ...
  • Like 1
Posted

It makes me so angry how they dismissed that woman's symptoms as being "in her head" ...

 

Yes, it makes suffering people even more lost, frustrated and isolated... And this is the sad common fate of SPS sufferers (of course, especially women). Céline herself was no exception - the proof is in Pieau & Tropéa's book, where her "mental illness" or at best "psychosomatic illness" is repeatedly suggested, by Scott Roeben of Vital Vegas among others, as a common rumor. Although perhaps no one said it to her face - as is often the case with other patients - people were obviously repeating it behind her back.

  • Like 1
Posted
after watching this video, you really have to feel sorry for the kids
Posted (edited)

 

But yeah -- what does it say about Celine that her background singer of 20+ years is not in her inner circle? Then again, as I've said before on the forum, everyone handles illness and strife differently -- and Celine has every right to handle things as she sees fit. It must have been so tough. And the Quebec media world is small.

 

But yeah, I feel like in each case the "getting better" both from Celine and Barnev is probably true -- some progress, but very incremental. Essentially, her condition is more stable and the symptoms are being treated but...well, there is no cure yet. Just my speculation. I hope she is responding well to treatments.

 

It says that Celine, like any employer, knows how to differentiate between business and personal life. She already dismissed Mego from her band even though she had a long history with him, meaning as an employer, she does not put that personal history in front of her when it's time to end somebody's contract. So when it comes to her personal life, Barnev has no special access to any private information about Celine's health other than the time he will have to go back to his job and perform with her on stage as a backup singer.

 

The community have created bonds with people that work with Celine making it look like 1 big family but at the end of the day he is just an employee for Celine whether it's Barnev or any other backup singer or instrument player as well.

Edited by Mudo
  • Like 2
Posted

Won't you text your employer of 20 years you're very close to, when they are battling with a life changing situation to ask how they are? You guys are being a bit ridiculous. Okay, maybe they don't have a connection, and he doesn't know anymore than us. But he must have asked. And the answer he'd gotten would be "she's doing better". Maybe that's what he's forwarding.

 

Or it could just be his own speculation with his observations of things. Maybe Celine finally told them about her condition and told them you could tell the media.

 

But I think we're being too judgemental. Just take the news as it is. It's better than knowing she's not good. I don't know what you guys want, but for me, it's definitely a better news than anything we've heard.

  • Like 1
Posted

Won't you text your employer of 20 years you're very close to, when they are battling with a life changing situation to ask how they are? You guys are being a bit ridiculous. Okay, maybe they don't have a connection, and he doesn't know anymore than us. But he must have asked. And the answer he'd gotten would be "she's doing better". Maybe that's what he's forwarding.

 

Or it could just be his own speculation with his observations of things. Maybe Celine finally told them about her condition and told them you could tell the media.

 

But I think we're being too judgemental. Just take the news as it is. It's better than knowing she's not good. I don't know what you guys want, but for me, it's definitely a better news than anything we've heard.

 

Exactly, even if they aren't in direct personal contact you would imagine when it was decided to cancel the tour a few weeks ago her band would have been told something. It is likely they were told she is doing better but not ready yet. That was essentially the message that was put out publicly too.

Posted

 

I miss this singing style of hers when she carefully saying each words. The way she sings it slower and calm. Reminds me of her singing A New Day Has Come in A New Day Las Vegas.

 

I’ve noticed her recent performances that she’s singing a bit faster compared to this one.

Posted

Rolling Stone is just weird. They gave bad reviews to MHWGO and called it "Celine Dion's song and the movie have aged very poorly...Now the song probably just makes you cringe" and ranked it the seventh worst song of 1990s.

They didn't include Celine on their top 200 artists list. And now they're trying to HONOUR her? Lmao, Rolling Stones, you make me laugh

  • Like 1
Posted

Drake, The Weeknd, Alanis Morisette higher than Céline? 🤨 Idk.

 

Also they have used such a had photo of Céline,😭

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

Yet through it all, Dion will tell you her greatest accomplishment was making her family — and her country — proud. And for that, our love for Celine will go on.

 

LOL

Edited by comingback
Posted (edited)

Has anyone seen this?

 

 

 

So many videos with a lot of views are saying that Céline Dion was "groomed" by her husband, and that she didn't need him to be a successful singer. Celine giving him the sun and moon was cringe. Do you all also think so?

 

 

Edited by CourageProject
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...