kaye2023 Posted October 10, 2023 at 04:29 AM Posted October 10, 2023 at 04:29 AM She's always been so wise. It's not uncommon for her to joke about her lack of education (though with humor, you know it's a tender, if not sore, point for her) and comment how totally uninvolved she is about the business side "because René knows best" and just focuses on the singing (which personally I think was on a schedule severely more taxing compared to any other performer in history so she deserves all the mental break she can get). I have come across some people's comments about how she's "dumb" not unlike a lot of celebrities. No doubt the hyper/rambly interviews and ESL issues don't help. Personally, I think she's sharp. Not in the bookish or academic way due to circumstances, but who the hell soaks up a second language as a teen in a matter of months like a sponge if not someone with brains? Her humor can be corny as hell when she's feeling goofy, but very quick-witted when needed. Heavily sheltered no doubt, but she can read people and situations better than most. I confess that's why I looked closer at her. I'm not a particularly musical/celebrity person, I knew who she was obvs, but never went beyond "ok, that's the popular singer." I was astonished to come across her short but on-point comment about anti-racism. Céline of all celebrities. The one who never really made political or social commentaries. Then it led knowing about her earlier Katrina comments, the bigger picture of how she viewed her burden caring for someone with cancer, understanding and committing with discipline what's demanded to achieve her career goals and value her gift, and more—what I find most extraordinary about Céline's personality is her EQ—through the roof, and amazing how her level of success only enhanced it when it would have corrupted most. And she's more media-savvy than she lets on/she appears. One of the best in the business, if I had to guess. She has a lot in common with Dolly Parton, and I say that as a gold standard compliment. Here's an interview I've recently watched. The Brit accent keeps cracking me up (we cannot blame her ears, its superpowers cannot always be controlled lol), but it says a lot about her personality, the bad, the good and the great:https://youtube.com/watch?v=qqW0sWzOeKo&pp=ygUNMyB0YWxrIGNlbGluZQ%3D%3D Divas Live 98 also showed a lot of her personality, why she shines as an extraordinary person, as much as she does as a performer. IMO René did a lot of things right as a manager, but not enforcing for her to complete her education was an egregious disservice to her. 3
RosieBarron Posted October 10, 2023 at 05:39 AM Posted October 10, 2023 at 05:39 AM It's not uncommon for her to joke about her lack of education (though with humor, you know it's a tender, if not sore, point for her) and comment how totally uninvolved she is about the business side "because René knows best" and just focuses on the singing (which personally I think was on a schedule severely more taxing compared to any other performer in history so she deserves all the mental break she can get). I have come across some people's comments about how she's "dumb" not unlike a lot of celebrities. No doubt the hyper/rambly interviews and ESL issues don't help. Personally, I think she's sharp. Not in the bookish or academic way due to circumstances, but who the hell soaks up a second language as a teen in a matter of months like a sponge if not someone with brains? Her humor can be corny as hell when she's feeling goofy, but very quick-witted when needed. Heavily sheltered no doubt, but she can read people and situations better than most. I confess that's why I looked closer at her. I'm not a particularly musical/celebrity person, I knew who she was obvs, but never went beyond "ok, that's the popular singer." I was astonished to come across her short but on-point comment about anti-racism. Céline of all celebrities. The one who never really made political or social commentaries. Then it led knowing about her earlier Katrina comments, the bigger picture of how she viewed her burden caring for someone with cancer, understanding and committing with discipline what's demanded to achieve her career goals and value her gift, and more—what I find most extraordinary about Céline's personality is her EQ—through the roof, and amazing how her level of success only enhanced it when it would have corrupted most. And she's more media-savvy than she lets on/she appears. One of the best in the business, if I had to guess. She has a lot in common with Dolly Parton, and I say that as a gold standard compliment. Here's an interview I've recently watched. The Brit accent keeps cracking me up (we cannot blame her ears, its superpowers cannot always be controlled lol), but it says a lot about her personality, the bad, the good and the great:https://youtube.com/watch?v=qqW0sWzOeKo&pp=ygUNMyB0YWxrIGNlbGluZQ%3D%3D Divas Live 98 also showed a lot of her personality, why she shines as an extraordinary person, as much as she does as a performer. IMO René did a lot of things right as a manager, but not enforcing for her to complete her education was an egregious disservice to her. I think by the time Rene met her the damage to her education was already done. Also I believe multiple of her siblings also dropped out of education early.
kaye2023 Posted October 10, 2023 at 06:05 AM Posted October 10, 2023 at 06:05 AM I think by the time Rene met her the damage to her education was already done. Also I believe multiple of her siblings also dropped out of education early. René was a smart man and finished college himself. He knew the value of education. He was the de facto guardian 20+ years older than his charge from backwoods Charlemagne. If he could incentivize learning a language you don't understand a word of to achieve a career goal, he could have incentivized the same for at least a HS diploma. Apologies for the comparison but apt, even Dolly Parton from the Appalachian mountains was advised to finish at least HS while ramping up for her career as a young teen. What more from Montreal which was their base. 1
kaye2023 Posted October 10, 2023 at 06:11 AM Posted October 10, 2023 at 06:11 AM I don't mean to disparage René or focus on his shortcomings as a manager. I only mentioned it because it seems to have put an imaginary limit for Céline (e.g. the times she's mentioned she doesn't feel equipped to write or have the confidence to share what she has written because she doesn't think she could express herself well even in French, her native language).
kaye2023 Posted October 10, 2023 at 06:29 AM Posted October 10, 2023 at 06:29 AM (edited) One last on her EQ, one of the endearing little anecdotes I have read about Céline: a guy shared that he was in Vegas one time with his elderly father entering whatever place. A woman neared the door almost at the same time as his father, but the woman rushed to courteously hold the door open and stepped to the side to let the old man pass first. Only when they were inside did the son inform his father the woman was Céline. Aww. Ain't she a sweetheart? I cannot imagine Streisand, Mariah or similar acting the same. They probably would have had their bodyguards shove the man to the side to let the diva pass first lol Edited October 10, 2023 at 06:30 AM by kaye2023 2
Zofia Posted October 10, 2023 at 01:01 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 01:01 PM It's not uncommon for her to joke about her lack of education (though with humor, you know it's a tender, if not sore, point for her) and comment how totally uninvolved she is about the business side "because René knows best" and just focuses on the singing (which personally I think was on a schedule severely more taxing compared to any other performer in history so she deserves all the mental break she can get). I have come across some people's comments about how she's "dumb" not unlike a lot of celebrities. No doubt the hyper/rambly interviews and ESL issues don't help. Personally, I think she's sharp. Not in the bookish or academic way due to circumstances, but who the hell soaks up a second language as a teen in a matter of months like a sponge if not someone with brains? Her humor can be corny as hell when she's feeling goofy, but very quick-witted when needed. Heavily sheltered no doubt, but she can read people and situations better than most. I confess that's why I looked closer at her. I'm not a particularly musical/celebrity person, I knew who she was obvs, but never went beyond "ok, that's the popular singer." I was astonished to come across her short but on-point comment about anti-racism. Céline of all celebrities. The one who never really made political or social commentaries. Then it led knowing about her earlier Katrina comments, the bigger picture of how she viewed her burden caring for someone with cancer, understanding and committing with discipline what's demanded to achieve her career goals and value her gift, and more—what I find most extraordinary about Céline's personality is her EQ—through the roof, and amazing how her level of success only enhanced it when it would have corrupted most. And she's more media-savvy than she lets on/she appears. One of the best in the business, if I had to guess. She has a lot in common with Dolly Parton, and I say that as a gold standard compliment. [...] IMO René did a lot of things right as a manager, but not enforcing for her to complete her education was an egregious disservice to her. Denise Bombardier, a true intellectual who had the opportunity to follow Céline closely during her Taking Chances world tour (without ever claiming to know her intimately), underlined this aspect on numerous occasions. Two examples: a fragment of an interview in the French show "Comment ça va bien!" hosted by Stéphane Berne (2016): "Look, me, I've interviewed French presidents, Canadian prime ministers, I've interviewed a US president, I've interviewed Marguerite Yourcenar and intellectuals; I can tell you one thing: [Céline] she's one of the most intelligent people I've met in my life. It's a kind of intelligence that's both intuitive and, what's more, she has the ability to penetrate other people. That is, when she goes into a room, she knows exactly which people are hostile to her." (from 3.30 min.) ...and the fragment of the last, very emotional interview conducted by Quebec journalist Richard Martineau shortly after the revelation of Céline's diagnosis in December 2022: "But do you see the kind of bullshit that can be said by people at university in Quebec City, Montreal or other universities? because she wouldn't have a university degree? I have university degrees, all the way up. And I can tell you one thing: I've rarely met anyone so intelligent - but it's not the same kind of intelligence, it's not a learned intelligence, it's a deep intelligence of knowing others. You have to have immense qualities... but they're not the same."https://player.fm/series/richard-martineau/celine-dion-elle-est-enfermee-dans-la-solitude-dit-denise-bombardier I think by the time Rene met her the damage to her education was already done. Also I believe multiple of her siblings also dropped out of education early. As for Céline's schooling, it seems that this was one of the major controversies between René (in this case Thérèse Tanguay's ally) and her former manager, Paul Lévesque, who insisted that a 12-year-old girl should continue her education. Unfortunately, René took over and took his protégée out of school. Of course, it's hard to ramble on about "what would happen if", but in this respect, I personally agree with Lévesque: pushing a child to work like an adult is never a good idea, neither in the factory nor in show business, and the mere argument that the child "hates his school" should never be enough to abandon his education. Moreover, this decision has often been detrimental to Céline, making her complex, more vulnerable and helpless in the face of criticism, more dependent on René and more likely to isolate herself and distrust people... 4
tshlw Posted October 10, 2023 at 02:45 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 02:45 PM As for Céline's schooling, it seems that this was one of the major controversies between René (in this case Thérèse Tanguay's ally) and her former manager, Paul Lévesque, who insisted that a 12-year-old girl should continue her education. But was it Rene's responsibility to make sure she get a HS diploma, would that not be the parents. Even if Rene went to her school to take her out that had to be with the blessing of Celine's parents. I feel sometimes Rene gets blamed for so much and we never once say anything about her mother. Like when she was younger and they say he was working her too hard. If her mother followed her everywhere then why did not Therese step in, and if she did not then she must not have felt she wasn't being over worked. He was not her guardian or her parent he was her manager. I agree she is highly intelligent and a lot of people do not see that. I think more her not being fluent in English when she first started in the US was more detrimental and made her feel unsure than not finishing HS. When someone is a non native speaker and not yet fluent they can come across as less educated when in reality that is not true they just don't have a mastery of the language yet. I think this is why a lot of people may have felt she wasn't as smart. 1 'I am, in life and death, the woman of only one man.' Celine Dion My Story, My Dream
RosieBarron Posted October 10, 2023 at 02:58 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 02:58 PM But was it Rene's responsibility to make sure she get a HS diploma, would that not be the parents. Even if Rene went to her school to take her out that had to be with the blessing of Celine's parents. I feel sometimes Rene gets blamed for so much and we never once say anything about her mother. Like when she was younger and they say he was working her too hard. If her mother followed her everywhere then why did not Therese step in, and if she did not then she must not have felt she wasn't being over worked. He was not her guardian or her parent he was her manager. I agree she is highly intelligent and a lot of people do not see that. I think more her not being fluent in English when she first started in the US was more detrimental and made her feel unsure than not finishing HS. When someone is a non native speaker and not yet fluent they can come across as less educated when in reality that is not true they just don't have a mastery of the language yet. I think this is why a lot of people may have felt she wasn't as smart. Exactly. Was sort of my point earlier. By the time that Rene was on the scene her education already had big holes in it as her parents seemed to take a pretty relaxed approach to it. It seems her parents weren't that bothered about it. It wasn't René's responsibility to ensure she completed school if they weren't pushing for it. We are also talking about a different era and how this would all be viewed in the early 80s in a very working class family. I for one wouldn't want to judge if those making the decision were right or wrong. They knew her and her individual situation best and on the whole seem to have made good decisions for her welfare.
Zofia Posted October 10, 2023 at 03:30 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 03:30 PM But was it Rene's responsibility to make sure she get a HS diploma, would that not be the parents. Even if Rene went to her school to take her out that had to be with the blessing of Celine's parents. I feel sometimes Rene gets blamed for so much and we never once say anything about her mother. Like when she was younger and they say he was working her too hard. If her mother followed her everywhere then why did not Therese step in, and if she did not then she must not have felt she wasn't being over worked. He was not her guardian or her parent he was her manager. I agree she is highly intelligent and a lot of people do not see that. I think more her not being fluent in English when she first started in the US was more detrimental and made her feel unsure than not finishing HS. When someone is a non native speaker and not yet fluent they can come across as less educated when in reality that is not true they just don't have a mastery of the language yet. I think this is why a lot of people may have felt she wasn't as smart. That's why I admitted that René was "in this case Thérèse Tanguay's ally". However, it seems important to take into consideration the fact that in the milieu closest to Céline at the time - her family and her new manager - René was the only graduate. Céline came from the provincial working class, and none of her parents or siblings had a formal education (young Thérèse, herself a good student, had ambitions to study to become a nurse, but this was impossible for family reasons). René, a Montrealer driven to study by his father, was probably - reluctantly - about to relaunch his career as a lawyer when he met Céline. And as for education, the more socially privileged you are, the greater your responsibility...
kaye2023 Posted October 10, 2023 at 04:26 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 04:26 PM (edited) Moreover, this decision has often been detrimental to Céline, making her complex, more vulnerable and helpless in the face of criticism, more dependent on René and more likely to isolate herself and distrust people... (Deep inhale) I will bite my tongue on this topic lol I think René delivered a good lot as a manager. My opinion on him being a husband-manager on the other hand... but I think we're on the same page on that issue. The least I could say is, glad he didn't rip her off, embarrass her with a scandal and having him around meant Céline was protected from awful men in the industry. The bar is low, but I do see how it benefited Céline. And I don't deny the times he made her happy. And thanks, I enjoyed reading the interview translation. As I don't speak French, I feel I have missed a lot of good interviews or coverage of her, especially as her demeanor in non-US interviews is different from her often hamming-it-up US ones. The good ones in English where she seems very relaxed and open seem far in between, like the ones with Jonathan Ross, Tom Power, Wayne Brady and Rosie O'Donnell. We also see how she's extraordinarily equipped to handle people at unexpected times, which just shows this is simply the real her, like with the drunk lady who went up the stage to hump her lol and this: https://youtube.com/watch?v=ljz2mTNy8W0&pp=ygUbQ2VsaW5lIGRpb24gc2h1dHMgZG93biBydWRl As for the schooling talk, yeah, IMO René was responsible for that being the de facto guardian, treated so much so by her mother that she freaked out about the relationship because she entrusted her daughter in his care, like a third parent. Correct me if I'm wrong, her mother remained back in Charlemagne except for special tours where she accompanied and didn't live with Céline in the Angelil household. So, yeah, guardianship was on him and he should have talked sense into her parents why Céline would need it, especially if their ultimate goal is worldwide success. Surely anyone can understand why any entertainer they're managing would need an education beyond 6th/7th grade? Didn't even have to be formal schooling, those distance programs child actors use would've worked quite as well. How can you expect someone to be inclined or have the confidence to want to understand contracts, accounting and other business stuff so she at least understands what's going on if the talent has a grade schooler's education? I would like to say it was just a matter of short-sightedness on Rene's part, but given what @Zofia mentioned that he was advised and argued with to the contrary but did it anyway, it was intentional convenient and a disservice in the long run. Eta: It's funny and delightful to watch her Treat Her Like A Lady performance, singing with a Jamaican patois lol I wondered what the feedback to that song was back then, cultural appropriation and all that, only to find out she's become an honorary Jamaican Queen! Lol and now a Jamican Auntie lol such is Céline's bottomless well of charm Edited October 10, 2023 at 04:43 PM by kaye2023 2
CelinesDIVO5 Posted October 10, 2023 at 05:06 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 05:06 PM René was a smart man and finished college himself. He knew the value of education. He was the de facto guardian 20+ years older than his charge from backwoods Charlemagne. If he could incentivize learning a language you don't understand a word of to achieve a career goal, he could have incentivized the same for at least a HS diploma. Apologies for the comparison but apt, even Dolly Parton from the Appalachian mountains was advised to finish at least HS while ramping up for her career as a young teen. What more from Montreal which was their base. I believe Celine did also try home schooling after she left public school and it just didn’t work out for her. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PL54qnRGM2gMatthew Charles - "Fix You" - Live at The Stonewall InnStonewall Sensation - Season 15Originally written and performed by Coldplay
tshlw Posted October 10, 2023 at 05:23 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 05:23 PM As for the schooling talk, yeah, IMO René was responsible for that being the de facto guardian, treated so much so by her mother that she freaked out about the relationship because she entrusted her daughter in his care, like a third parent. Correct me if I'm wrong, her mother remained back in Charlemagne except for special tours where she accompanied and didn't live with Céline in the Angelil household. So, yeah, guardianship was on him and he should have talked sense into her parents why Céline would need it, especially if their ultimate goal is worldwide success. I will deep inhale as well as I am sure I am on the other side of your opinion on Rene. And all the things you listed Rene did do is very much why she is the way she is and why we all love her and for me sets the bar very high. I can't even imagine her navigating the music world in the 90s without Rene. But where did you get her mother only went with her on special tours. Based on what the entire family has said she was always with Celine until she was 18 not just sometimes. And she never went and lived at the Angelil household. So again Rene was not like her third parent. He taught her showbiz he was not her guardian. She freaked out not because she entrusted him as her manager and fact he was twice divorced and so much older. Have you ever read her biography My Story, My Dream? Rene really interacted with her on a much more professional level than as a parent would. I just listened to the interview Celine and Rene gave for when doing the tribute show for Eddy Marnay after he died and as each has said before Eddy was much more a second father to her. Also Eddy was a very educated man and Rene and the Dion family very much respected him and doesn't seem he felt she need to get a diploma either. I very much feel she could handle any of the business side if she wanted but numbers and deciding on how much they paid her and all that was never anything she wanted to be part of and am sure even after Rene died she was not involved much in that. Also nothing against Celine but she tends to exaggerate on how little she was involved on things. Her saying all she did was sing was not totally accurate in multiple interviews over the years with Rene and herself, also members of their team they talked how she got more and more involved in all things artistically. And how many times has she said no business talk at home. She wanted to be a mom. Yes she was more involved after Rene passed not just because he was gone but also her children were now older and did not need her as much. If the twins had still been very young I am sure she would not have involved herself as much or done have the thing she did like the fashion shows after Rene passed. And yes I am very much team Rene, and no I do not believe he was perfect and sure could have done things better. As Michelle Obama herself has said marriage is not easy and anyone who says it is, is lying. So of course they had their ups and downs like all couples add to that they worked together the fact they stayed married and were happy together says a lot to me. 1 'I am, in life and death, the woman of only one man.' Celine Dion My Story, My Dream
comingback Posted October 10, 2023 at 05:25 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 05:25 PM (edited) Celine has always said that she wanted to become an international star. Do you guys remember her first interview in English 40 years ago? It was in broken English and Rene helped her (he was in the background). By that time (she was 15 years old), they (Rene/parents) must have realized that she needs a better education. Then she went to the language school to learn English. Celine is not dumb, she has a high Emotional Intelligence. But I also think that her parents shouldn't have taken her out of school. Edited October 10, 2023 at 05:31 PM by comingback 1
jpatdeleon09 Posted October 10, 2023 at 07:00 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 07:00 PM Haven’t you guys noticed how Céline’s speaking voice/gestures changed over the years. https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSNYfccEg/ 1
maki_Dion-er Posted October 10, 2023 at 07:06 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 07:06 PM Haven’t you guys noticed how Céline’s speaking voice/gestures changed over the years. https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSNYfccEg/ I'm forever sad Celine and Whitney never got a chance to work together. At least we know Whitney knew of Celine's respect & admiration for her. 2
PuraVida Posted October 10, 2023 at 10:52 PM Posted October 10, 2023 at 10:52 PM Haven’t you guys noticed how Céline’s speaking voice/gestures changed over the years. https://vt.tiktok.com/ZSNYfccEg/ Yes, I even saw comments on interviews from her in the early 90s and people in the comments claimed it wasn't her or the videos were edited.... when it totally was her speaking. 1
kaye2023 Posted October 11, 2023 at 01:25 AM Posted October 11, 2023 at 01:25 AM I believe Celine did also try home schooling after she left public school and it just didn’t work out for her. Wish they didn't give up on it, even when she was in her 20s. If you love someone, you want them capable and ready at any time. All parties are lucky Réne lived to his 70s (and we all wish he could have been around for twenty more). I can't imagine where and how sheltered Céline might have ended up if had he suddenly become unable to be her manager while they were still on their way up (death, illness) and she ended up with a Col Tom Parker or Scooter as new manager.
kaye2023 Posted October 11, 2023 at 01:43 AM Posted October 11, 2023 at 01:43 AM Seeing that ^ vid of young Céline, the stars really aligned for her that she found success in Quebec and France before the US. It was a great way to build her confidence before conquering a harsher and more lookist market, which by then she already had a little glow up. Although, personally, I find her natural looks just as beautiful. She has always made fun or has been critical of the way she looked back then, like in Eurovision, but aside from the unfortunate skirt, and 80s hair, I find her face beautiful. Shes has such lovely expressive eyes. I love this performance and her styling here. So light and young: https://youtube.com/watch?v=3eAJNjB-uFw
jpatdeleon09 Posted October 11, 2023 at 05:36 AM Posted October 11, 2023 at 05:36 AM I'm forever sad Celine and Whitney never got a chance to work together. At least we know Whitney knew of Celine's respect & admiration for her. Someone said before here in forum that Celine and Whitney planned to record a song together I think it was back in 2009. And I forgot the reason why it didn’t push through. I don’t know if it’s true.
jpatdeleon09 Posted October 11, 2023 at 05:39 AM Posted October 11, 2023 at 05:39 AM And I just remember now again about Celine have written a song for a movie that I believe it was supposed to be for the “Love Again” movie or the next album? I don’t if you guys remember about that detail having Celine written a song. I wonder what happened to that…. 1
PuraVida Posted October 11, 2023 at 07:27 AM Posted October 11, 2023 at 07:27 AM Oh -- I just read that the server was taken down because they needed to downgrade to a server with much less storage. This is because it was cheaper, due to lack of funds and donators. You will see that Koolan made a post in the "Multimedia" section about it.
Shaun Posted October 11, 2023 at 08:26 AM Posted October 11, 2023 at 08:26 AM (edited) Short bit from The Sun website acknowledging Celine as Queen of Vegas and the highest earner: Known as the Queen of Vegas, it’s little wonder that Celine Dion holds the title for the highest grossing Vegas residency of all time. The performer, 55, who has sold more than 200 million records worldwide, first banked an astonishing £299 million with her show A New Day, which ran between March 2003 and December 2007. Performing 717 shows to a total of 3 million lucky fans at The Colosseum at Caesars Palace, Celine is said to have commanded an impressive £417,000 per performance. The Canadian singer returned to the strip in March 2011 for another 70 performances of her show Celine, which netted her a cool £15.5 million before wrapping in June 2019. Nick says: “Celine is a powerhouse performer with an incredible voice - she is undoubtedly one of the biggest stars in the world so it’s no surprise she has made the most cash. With breathtaking effects from the team behind Cirque Du Soleil, she wowed audiences with water-soaked performances of My Heart Will Go On. There were multiple costume changes and audiences loved her chat in between songs.” https://www.thesun.co.uk/fabulous/23643448/ultimate-las-vegas-residency-rich-list/ Edited October 11, 2023 at 08:27 AM by Shaun 4 Bringing you the world's only Celine Dion podcast show since 2014.Find us on Soundcloud, Apple Podcasts, Spotify & Amazon Music.
PuraVida Posted October 11, 2023 at 10:55 PM Posted October 11, 2023 at 10:55 PM (edited) Denise Bombardier, a true intellectual who had the opportunity to follow Céline closely during her Taking Chances world tour (without ever claiming to know her intimately), underlined this aspect on numerous occasions. Two examples: a fragment of an interview in the French show "Comment ça va bien!" hosted by Stéphane Berne (2016): "Look, me, I've interviewed French presidents, Canadian prime ministers, I've interviewed a US president, I've interviewed Marguerite Yourcenar and intellectuals; I can tell you one thing: [Céline] she's one of the most intelligent people I've met in my life. It's a kind of intelligence that's both intuitive and, what's more, she has the ability to penetrate other people. That is, when she goes into a room, she knows exactly which people are hostile to her." (from 3.30 min.)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uc9dlQUXpTY ...and the fragment of the last, very emotional interview conducted by Quebec journalist Richard Martineau shortly after the revelation of Céline's diagnosis in December 2022: "But do you see the kind of bullshit that can be said by people at university in Quebec City, Montreal or other universities? because she wouldn't have a university degree? I have university degrees, all the way up. And I can tell you one thing: I've rarely met anyone so intelligent - but it's not the same kind of intelligence, it's not a learned intelligence, it's a deep intelligence of knowing others. You have to have immense qualities... but they're not the same."https://player.fm/se...nise-bombardier As for Céline's schooling, it seems that this was one of the major controversies between René (in this case Thérèse Tanguay's ally) and her former manager, Paul Lévesque, who insisted that a 12-year-old girl should continue her education. Unfortunately, René took over and took his protégée out of school. Of course, it's hard to ramble on about "what would happen if", but in this respect, I personally agree with Lévesque: pushing a child to work like an adult is never a good idea, neither in the factory nor in show business, and the mere argument that the child "hates his school" should never be enough to abandon his education. Moreover, this decision has often been detrimental to Céline, making her complex, more vulnerable and helpless in the face of criticism, more dependent on René and more likely to isolate herself and distrust people... Oh this reminds me I came across this parody of Denise interviewing Celine recently: Edited October 11, 2023 at 10:56 PM by PuraVida
ryba Posted October 12, 2023 at 07:52 PM Posted October 12, 2023 at 07:52 PM (edited) She is very intelligent. I think it's due to the fact that she was the youngest of 14 children and she grew up with adults. She was also surrounded by a huge number of people all her childhood and this is where her good knowledge about people comes from. She might not have received the basic school education, but so what? She was laser focused on perfecting her craft, which is her singing skills, and trained her voice like an athlete. This is her education. And the rest she learned through life. Does that make her less intelligent than other people? Absolutely not. She is the best example that you can be highly successful in life when you focus on what you can do best instead of following some rules that are imposed on you by some systems. Also regarding the argument about her not being able to understand business contracts because she left school: you don't learn specific stuff like this at school as a child anyway. And even if you learned the basics, it won't get you anywhere in the world of showbusiness, because it's a whole different level that Edited October 12, 2023 at 08:15 PM by ryba 3
ryba Posted October 12, 2023 at 08:45 PM Posted October 12, 2023 at 08:45 PM (edited) René was a smart man and finished college himself. He knew the value of education. He was the de facto guardian 20+ years older than his charge from backwoods Charlemagne. If he could incentivize learning a language you don't understand a word of to achieve a career goal, he could have incentivized the same for at least a HS diploma. Apologies for the comparison but apt, even Dolly Parton from the Appalachian mountains was advised to finish at least HS while ramping up for her career as a young teen. What more from Montreal which was their base.What would a HS diploma give her? Absolutely nothing. She was not interested in that. All she wanted was to sing and now she is a multi millionaire. And look where the people with HS diplomas ended up. Certainly not where Celine is. I think Celine would now be an excellent voice coach and singing teacher. However, she doesn't need that cause the money she would get from that would be ridiculous compared to what she earns as a performer. Edited October 12, 2023 at 08:47 PM by ryba
PuraVida Posted October 12, 2023 at 09:37 PM Posted October 12, 2023 at 09:37 PM Also Celine had a miserable time at school. Was RC homeschooled for his entire education? What about Nelson/Eddy -- did they or are they attending a regular school? It never crossed my mind before, but now I'm curious.
tshlw Posted October 12, 2023 at 10:31 PM Posted October 12, 2023 at 10:31 PM Also Celine had a miserable time at school. Was RC homeschooled for his entire education? What about Nelson/Eddy -- did they or are they attending a regular school? It never crossed my mind before, but now I'm curious. RC was home schooled until after the Taking Chances tour. Then they settled in Florida after the tour he want to a school in person. Celine and Rene would then drive him to school. If watch 3 Boys and a show learn a lot of this. During that time Celine and Rene were doing invitro. Once Celine went back to performing in Vegas they were basing her time in Vegas around RC's school schedule. But that still meant he had to be out of school a number of weeks. Believe this caused RC problems. Finally at the school year starting in Fall of 2013 RC went back to being home schooled. Nelson/Eddy were always homeschool. 1 'I am, in life and death, the woman of only one man.' Celine Dion My Story, My Dream
PuraVida Posted October 12, 2023 at 11:42 PM Posted October 12, 2023 at 11:42 PM RC was home schooled until after the Taking Chances tour. Then they settled in Florida after the tour he want to a school in person. Celine and Rene would then drive him to school. If watch 3 Boys and a show learn a lot of this. During that time Celine and Rene were doing invitro. Once Celine went back to performing in Vegas they were basing her time in Vegas around RC's school schedule. But that still meant he had to be out of school a number of weeks. Believe this caused RC problems. Finally at the school year starting in Fall of 2013 RC went back to being home schooled. Nelson/Eddy were always homeschool. It's odd that Nelson/Eddy were eternally homeschooled since they were based in Vegas for their whole life. Then of course, the pandemic threw all education for a loop.
tshlw Posted October 13, 2023 at 02:21 AM Posted October 13, 2023 at 02:21 AM It's odd that Nelson/Eddy were eternally homeschooled since they were based in Vegas for their whole life. Then of course, the pandemic threw all education for a loop. I have to believe because she was still was traveling to Europe for tours when not performing in Vegas, and they did come with her until the Courage tour on these tours. I believe having to take RC out of school weeks at a time probably caused him to have problems and lead to them going back to home schooling. Also with her being such a big star can't be easy to find a school where you are treated as just another student and not Celine's sons. Also right when the twins would be starting school Rene was still battling cancer so Celine might not have wanted to have them away from home knowing anytime the boys could lose their father. 'I am, in life and death, the woman of only one man.' Celine Dion My Story, My Dream
Recommended Posts