3682 replies to this topic

[ubulka]

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 08:53 PM, said:

If Sony releases a 1 CD edition only, you hate them for that, now that you got a 2 CD edition as well, you hate them because 2 or 3 of your favourite songs are not included. You always hate someone for something. That's getting very boring now!

Why can't you just enjoy the music of Céline and let the others do that too?

Agree with BORING!  

[GoldenLeaf]

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 02:53 PM, said:

You Sony/René haters are so funny... You hate Sony/René because they didn't include fake songs on the tracklist that was only a really bad rumour. No one ever told that there will be more than 2 unreleased tracks on this album. Usually no one puts more than 2 unreleased songs on a greatest hits album.

On Ne Change Pas had 4 new unreleased songs!  

[Loup_garou]

GTSW   it was bad for the album a mistake as a single and now in the greatest hits?????   ...HYEBIL not my cup of tea either ....CTM ...nice song but not for this kind of album....TFTEISYF .....wroooong....not a hit but an extra on a previous greatest hits even a cut out of Las Vegas......jajaja and LCMM definitely the Viagra's song it won't give up ......Does the Celine Team really think that it was her biggest hit after MHWGO???     I agree with WDMHBN, IYAMT, and Unison ............for the rest i guess it's a nice treat for someone that doesn't have ANY Celine albums

Edited by Loup_garou, 04 September 2008 - 01:02 PM.

[Timster]

Ronny83, on Sep 4 2008, 07:57 PM, said:

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 08:53 PM, said:

You Sony/René haters are so funny... You hate Sony/René because they didn't include fake songs on the tracklist that was only a really bad rumour. No one ever told that there will be more than 2 unreleased tracks on this album. Usually no one puts more than 2 unreleased songs on a greatest hits album.

You always say Sony don't care about Céline.... but at the same time in another thread you welcome the fact that she was awarded by Sony after selling 7 million albums in Canada and having the most platinum awards there.

If Sony releases a 1 CD edition only, you hate them for that, now that you got a 2 CD edition as well, you hate them because 2 or 3 of your favourite songs are not included. You always hate someone for something. That's getting very boring now!

Why can't you just enjoy the music of Céline and let the others do that too?

I fully agree.  

Absolutely. Very well said!  

[Prince Whiskers]

Calypso, on Sep 5 2008, 02:50 AM, said:

I'll just download on mIRC ''My Love (New version)'' and ''There Comes A Time''.[/b]

Don't give me ideas.

[VinnyT.]

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 08:53 PM, said:

You Sony/René haters are so funny... You hate Sony/René because they didn't include fake songs on the tracklist that was only a really bad rumour. No one ever told that there will be more than 2 unreleased tracks on this album. Usually no one puts more than 2 unreleased songs on a greatest hits album.

You always say Sony don't care about Céline.... but at the same time in another thread you welcome the fact that she was awarded by Sony after selling 7 million albums in Canada and having the most platinum awards there.

If Sony releases a 1 CD edition only, you hate them for that, now that you got a 2 CD edition as well, you hate them because 2 or 3 of your favourite songs are not included. You always hate someone for something. That's getting very boring now!

Why can't you just enjoy the music of Céline and let the others do that too?

I agree, Sony was not supposed to choose what we like, I never thought that, it was not their intention , so let's enjoy our favorite singer!

[VinnyT.]

Calypso, on Sep 4 2008, 08:59 PM, said:

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 02:53 PM, said:

You Sony/René haters are so funny... You hate Sony/René because they didn't include fake songs on the tracklist that was only a really bad rumour. No one ever told that there will be more than 2 unreleased tracks on this album. Usually no one puts more than 2 unreleased songs on a greatest hits album.

On Ne Change Pas had 4 new unreleased songs!  

3, ma nouvelle france was on the soundtrack already

[Cambroneroj]

Im soo glad to have all of these songs in one cd , i dont have ANY of them! lol j/k  well guys this collection is for people who like Celine but are not HUGE fans like we are.  It's a nice compilation if you ask a non-Celine fan.

[nano]

Cambroneroj, on Sep 4 2008, 10:03 PM, said:

It's a nice compilation if you ask a non-Celine fan.

[VinnyT.]

Cambroneroj, on Sep 4 2008, 09:03 PM, said:

Im soo glad to have all of these songs in one cd , i dont have ANY of them! lol j/k  well guys this collection is for people who like Celine but are not HUGE fans like we are.  It's a nice compilation if you ask a non-Celine fan.

yes I read good reactions on no celine's forums, many want to buy it

[Ronny83]

Calypso, on Sep 4 2008, 08:59 PM, said:

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 02:53 PM, said:

You Sony/René haters are so funny... You hate Sony/René because they didn't include fake songs on the tracklist that was only a really bad rumour. No one ever told that there will be more than 2 unreleased tracks on this album. Usually no one puts more than 2 unreleased songs on a greatest hits album.

On Ne Change Pas had 4 new unreleased songs!  

2 unreleased ("Je Ne Vous Oublie Pas", "Tous Les Secrets"), 1 bonus track (the duet with Il Divo) + 1 already released ("Nouvelle France").

According to you, "Dance With My Father" is an unreleased track, too.  

[GoldenLeaf]

Ronny83, on Sep 4 2008, 03:06 PM, said:

Calypso, on Sep 4 2008, 08:59 PM, said:

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 02:53 PM, said:

You Sony/René haters are so funny... You hate Sony/René because they didn't include fake songs on the tracklist that was only a really bad rumour. No one ever told that there will be more than 2 unreleased tracks on this album. Usually no one puts more than 2 unreleased songs on a greatest hits album.

On Ne Change Pas had 4 new unreleased songs!  

2 unreleased ("Je Ne Vous Oublie Pas", "Tous Les Secrets"), 1 bonus track (the duet with Il Divo) + 1 already released ("Nouvelle France").

According to you, "Dance With My Father" is an unreleased track, too.  

Well, at least ''Je Ne Vous Oublie Pas", "Tous Les Secrets'' and ''I Believe in You'' were 3 brand-new songs and ''Ma Nouvelle France'' was an already known unreleased track. Now we only get ''There Comes A Time'' as brand-new song and ''Dance With My Father'' as already known unreleased track.  

Edited by Calypso, 04 September 2008 - 01:13 PM.

[Myheartwillgoon-91]

I will buy the greatest hits album, upload it and adding tracks:

Let Your Heart Decide
I Knew I Loved You
Dance With My Father
All Because Of You
The Reason I Go On

[VinnyT.]

Calypso, on Sep 4 2008, 09:11 PM, said:

Ronny83, on Sep 4 2008, 03:06 PM, said:

Calypso, on Sep 4 2008, 08:59 PM, said:

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 02:53 PM, said:

You Sony/René haters are so funny... You hate Sony/René because they didn't include fake songs on the tracklist that was only a really bad rumour. No one ever told that there will be more than 2 unreleased tracks on this album. Usually no one puts more than 2 unreleased songs on a greatest hits album.

On Ne Change Pas had 4 new unreleased songs!  

2 unreleased ("Je Ne Vous Oublie Pas", "Tous Les Secrets"), 1 bonus track (the duet with Il Divo) + 1 already released ("Nouvelle France").

According to you, "Dance With My Father" is an unreleased track, too.  

Well, at least ''Je Ne Vous Oublie Pas", "Tous Les Secrets'' and ''I Believe in You'' were 3 brand-new songs and ''Ma Nouvelle France'' was an already known unreleased track. Now we only get ''There Comes A Time'' as brand-new song and ''Dance With My Father'' as already known unreleased track.  

and my love new version so almost 3 lol

[anewdayhascome]

but also on 3 disc edition was a song with Marc i don't remember the title in french plus haut et moi? sth like that! for many people it was new as well i think

[$P!K&]

I'm not angry because I miss any music that i love. I'm angry because it's the same thing as always and ONE new song! ONE! Where is let me be your solider? Sony it's mercenary. Old songs and ONE new? C'mom we knew there's more. I hope one day sony will paid atention to celine fans. They could make The first cd one the best of and the second with some rarities and never released songs in respect of the fans. But no.... It's the same thing EVER. It's simple this time i'll donwload the new songs and the crazy ones could buy it. It's a waste of money.

Edited by $P!K&, 04 September 2008 - 01:23 PM.

[firebird]

Actually I have to say, the songs I'd really consider essential on this one are
The Reason (already wrote about that one above)
My Heart Will Go On: I think everyone knows why it is
All By Myself / The Power Of Love: Some might pick on these songs not being originals, but Celine's versions are definitive. Just listen to "All By Myself" I don't think anyone gets this song as good as Celine does.
It's All Coming Back To Me Now: This is Celine's tour de force über-genius song. It is essential, can't deny it. It will come back again and again.
A New Day Has Come: This is the essential new Celine: stripped off excessive over-use of reverbe (I know people loved her for that in the 90ies), going for a straight and catchy sound. She came back with that song - and look where it has led her
River Deep Mountain High: Well, the song itself is essential, but in my opinion it is essential even more for being a testimony of the "almost-collaboration" with Phil Spector

as for the rest: interchangeable, exchangeable hit songs (they could take anything from her back catalogue and label it "essential" doesn't mean it is)

[VinnyT.]

anewdayhascome, on Sep 4 2008, 09:19 PM, said:

but also on 3 disc edition was a song with Marc i don't remember the title in french plus haut et moi? sth like that! for many people it was new as well i think

mario pelchat, but we dont have 3 disc yet dont suggest them more!

Talking about Let me be your soldier we know it exits, but none confirmed should have been e part of this album  

Edited by VinnyT., 04 September 2008 - 01:31 PM.

[GoldenLeaf]

VinnyT., on Sep 4 2008, 03:14 PM, said:

Calypso, on Sep 4 2008, 09:11 PM, said:

Ronny83, on Sep 4 2008, 03:06 PM, said:

Calypso, on Sep 4 2008, 08:59 PM, said:

Chabby, on Sep 4 2008, 02:53 PM, said:

You Sony/René haters are so funny... You hate Sony/René because they didn't include fake songs on the tracklist that was only a really bad rumour. No one ever told that there will be more than 2 unreleased tracks on this album. Usually no one puts more than 2 unreleased songs on a greatest hits album.

On Ne Change Pas had 4 new unreleased songs!  

2 unreleased ("Je Ne Vous Oublie Pas", "Tous Les Secrets"), 1 bonus track (the duet with Il Divo) + 1 already released ("Nouvelle France").

According to you, "Dance With My Father" is an unreleased track, too.  

Well, at least ''Je Ne Vous Oublie Pas", "Tous Les Secrets'' and ''I Believe in You'' were 3 brand-new songs and ''Ma Nouvelle France'' was an already known unreleased track. Now we only get ''There Comes A Time'' as brand-new song and ''Dance With My Father'' as already known unreleased track.  

and my love new version so almost 3 lol

I wouldn't consider My Love (Studio Tour Version) as a brand-new song as we already know it.

[Shamrock_1982]

Im annoyed that ''If I Can Dream'' didnt make it on there, but I don't think that Elvis's people would have allowed it!
The rest of the songs on there is no big surprise to be honest considering the concept, but I have to agree with other fans that ''is'' and I think '' iagltow'' should have been on there...

But I cant wait to hear ''there comes a time''

Darren.

Edited by Ire23, 04 September 2008 - 01:37 PM.

[Thomas]

firebird, on Sep 4 2008, 08:27 PM, said:

It's All Coming Back To Me Now: This is Celine's tour de force über-genius song. It is essential, can't deny it. It will come back again and again.

Agreed. Although I really hope it's the full version as the one that appeard on ATW is nowhere near as good. This song does not benefit from being cut up.

[celineargento]

I'm still very angry, furious to be accurate.
I'm not complaning about the "old" hits, except for some exclusions such as "OH" , "IS" and "WDMHBN". It's the fact of ONE and only ONE new song what annoys me.
I still can't get over this fact

[Taking Chances]

One Heart, The First Time I Ever Saw Your Face, The Reason, Seduces Me and Alone, why are they there? At least "One Heart", it's so upsetting because Sony isn't listening to the fans at all. Look at how many people requested I Surrender, and One Heart is what they come up with? The person in charge really needs to get fired, because this is basically just All The Way one more time. As this is a compilation album, the least they could do after including Celine's biggest hits are listening to the fans! Why did we post our own tracklist for this when they don't even bother listening to any of us? I really hope this is the last album Celine records for Sony.

Again, as this is a compilation, they really should listen to the people who love Celine Dion's music the most. The fans, and what we want.

Edited by Taking Chances, 04 September 2008 - 01:55 PM.

[Bruno Portugal]

I quite like this tracklist! No big surprises but no really big mistakes...

"The Reason", "Call The Man", "River Deep Mountain High", "The Prayer", "Dance With My Father"...  

Of course I don't understand why to include the terrible "One Heart" and forget "I Surrender"...    but I think I will survive to this...

Now I just hope that "It's All Coming Back To Me Now" will be the full version song from the "Falling Into You" album.

[VinnyT.]

Taking Chances, on Sep 4 2008, 09:52 PM, said:

it's so upsetting because Sony isn't listening to the fans at all. Look at how many people requested I Surrender

Why they should listen to fans?

[troystar]

Very dissapointed...I wonder how much the 2 CD's will go for. She really needed a singles discography. I'm not sure I will be buying this

All these song could be replaced by hits

09. Tell Him (& Barbara Steisand) This was not a hit
04. Only One Road
11. Seduces Me
12. The First Time I Ever Saw Your Face...why is this here seriously?  
16. Call The Man....was this a single?  
17. Goodbye's The Saddest Word

Where is??
Where Does My Heart Beat Now Top 5 Billboard hit  
Unison A huge hit in Canada
If You Asked Me To Top 3 Billboard hit
Is Nothing Sacred Amazing unreleased song  
The Power Of The Dream Olympic song  

Or even
Nothing Broken But My Heart
(If There Was) Any Other Way A hit in Canada
Water from the Moon  
Did You Give Enough Love
Treat Her Like A Lady

[Ronny83]

Bruno Portugal, on Sep 4 2008, 09:55 PM, said:

Of course I don't understand why to include the terrible "One Heart" and forget "I Surrender"...    but I think I will survive to this...

Because "One Heart" was a single and "I Surrender" wasn't.  

[Timster]

Thomas, on Sep 4 2008, 08:42 PM, said:

firebird, on Sep 4 2008, 08:27 PM, said:

It's All Coming Back To Me Now: This is Celine's tour de force über-genius song. It is essential, can't deny it. It will come back again and again.

Agreed. Although I really hope it's the full version as the one that appeard on ATW is nowhere near as good. This song does not benefit from being cut up.

That version was included on the Complete Best in Japan.

It sounds quite abrupt when the cut it at 'But you were history with the slamming of the door', but I do like the final 'noooow' because the back ground music all winds down and it sounds quite cool.

[Taking Chances]

VinnyT., on Sep 4 2008, 02:55 PM, said:

Taking Chances, on Sep 4 2008, 09:52 PM, said:

it's so upsetting because Sony isn't listening to the fans at all. Look at how many people requested I Surrender

Why they should listen to fans?

That's pretty obvious. The one song most of the fans wanted was I Surrender, and they left it out. And they included the poor song One Heart. There is absolutely no logic there. And they should have replaced the other songs I mentioned too, with new songs or fan favorites.

Quote

Because "One Heart" was a single and "I Surrender" wasn't.

They still don't need to release it over again when it's bad. To be fair, it was a flop. A big flop, and if they can correct the mistake by not dragging the song with them on any album in the future. That'll be wise. The songs that never became a single from an album shouldn't be thrown away, at least not when she's not recording much new songs for this album. Sony should really use these songs for all they're worth instead.

Edited by Taking Chances, 04 September 2008 - 02:13 PM.

[VinnyT.]

Taking Chances, on Sep 4 2008, 10:07 PM, said:

VinnyT., on Sep 4 2008, 02:55 PM, said:

Taking Chances, on Sep 4 2008, 09:52 PM, said:

it's so upsetting because Sony isn't listening to the fans at all. Look at how many people requested I Surrender

Why they should listen to fans?

That's pretty obvious. The one song most of the fans wanted was I Surrender, and they left it out. And they included the poor song One Heart. There is absolutely no logic there. And they should have replaced the other songs I mentioned too, with new songs or fan favorites.

fans want also other songs but they dont know it for sure

BTW they included all radio single songs so their tracklist makes sense