Celine recorded Symphonic Show - France 2, Dec, 29

[thevoice]

yeahhh it's near the end of the song....i cant wait to hear her hit those powerful notes...it's one of those songs that u just cant do it "ok" - there is not such thing .

2 options : 1 - celine sings it as powerful as ever 2 - celine cant hit those notes with as much power as she used to .

 

after tonight there will be no more questions about her voice - this is the first time in years that we r going to hear celine singing a very hard song (one of her hardest) 100% live - it's risky and if she did it she probably knew she could

 

guys - in less than 12 hours the biggest voice ever is back (hopefuly)    

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Don't expect that much or you might be disappointed.

I personaly just hope she can hit those notes again.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

yeahh that's the problem with me...i always expect too much .

it's just that i'm waiting for this performance for months now and i really want her to nail it

[Céline's Blues]

yeahhh it's near the end of the song....i cant wait to hear her hit those powerful notes...it's one of those songs that u just cant do it "ok" - there is not such thing .

2 options : 1 - celine sings it as powerful as ever 2 - celine cant hit those notes with as much power as she used to .

On Live A Paris she barely sang with power like she did in 1991 on the Adisq gala. There was no comparison and nontheless she did well. There are many shades of grey.

[thevoice]

yeahhh it's near the end of the song....i cant wait to hear her hit those powerful notes...it's one of those songs that u just cant do it "ok" - there is not such thing .

2 options : 1 - celine sings it as powerful as ever 2 - celine cant hit those notes with as much power as she used to .

On Live A Paris she barely sang with power like she did in 1991 on the Adisq gala. There was no comparison and nontheless she did well. There are many shades of grey.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

siur , we didnt hear celine nail it big time like she used to for almost 5 years . the last time she gave a perfect vocal performance of a hard song to sing was during the 2001 telethon with the most amazing rendition ever to GOD BLESS AMERICA .

 

since then she mostly sings live easy songs with one note here and there...this is the first time in all of those years that she is going to sing live a very hard song - that's why i'm so excited and that's why i want it to be perfect cause i know the next time we'll have the chance to hear her nail notes like this will be around 2015

[Céline's Blues]

siur , we didnt hear celine nail it big time like she used to for almost 5 years . the last time she gave a perfect vocal performance of a hard song to sing was during the 2001 telethon with the most amazing rendition ever to GOD BLESS AMERICA .

 

since then she mostly sings live easy songs with one note here and there...this is the first time in all of those years that she is going to sing live a very hard song - that's why i'm so excited and that's why i want it to be perfect cause i know the next time we'll have the chance to hear her nail notes like this will be around 2015

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Not quite. It's up to you how you define "nailing a performance". To me she nails every single songs she performs with "Brule Pas Tes Doigts" and "Destin" being the best examples.

 

It would be more appropriate to say she hasn't performed the Blues for 5 years now...

[thevoice]

siur , we didnt hear celine nail it big time like she used to for almost 5 years . the last time she gave a perfect vocal performance of a hard song to sing was during the 2001 telethon with the most amazing rendition ever to GOD BLESS AMERICA .

 

since then she mostly sings live easy songs with one note here and there...this is the first time in all of those years that she is going to sing live a very hard song - that's why i'm so excited and that's why i want it to be perfect cause i know the next time we'll have the chance to hear her nail notes like this will be around 2015

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Not quite. It's up to you how you define "nailing a performance". To me she nails every single songs she performs with "Brule Pas Tes Doigts" and "Destin" being the best examples.

 

It would be more appropriate to say she hasn't performed the Blues for 5 years now...

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

u know exactly what i mean - she didnt hit those long powerful notes that last 20 seconds each ...i miss it .

she didnt sing blues she didnt sing ABM and other huge hits that people love and would do anything to hear again live

[isurrender]

after tonight there will be no more questions about her voice - this is the first time in years that we r going to hear celine singing a very hard song (one of her hardest) 100% live - it's risky and if she did it she probably knew she could

 

You make the situation so dramatic!!! So exagerated!!!

She told herself she wasn't in a good shape that night due to the time difference :she had not slept a lot and she was tired.

Her voice changes every single day! Come on...

 

I'm sure it will be crap and then you will be the first to complain about it even if you KNOW NOW it won't be so good as before!

 

 

we didnt hear celine nail it big time like she used to for almost 5 years . the last time she gave a perfect vocal performance of a hard song to sing was during the 2001 telethon with the most amazing rendition ever to GOD BLESS AMERICA .

 

since then she mostly sings live easy songs with one note here and there...this is the first time in all of those years that she is going to sing live a very hard song - that's why i'm so excited and that's why i want it to be perfect cause i know the next time we'll have the chance to hear her nail notes like this will be around 2015

 

And I surrender?... even if in Vegas it's not live she had to sing it live at least once because it's not the same version of the cd.

And "aren't they all our children"? And "L'envie"?

[isurrender]

siur , we didnt hear celine nail it big time like she used to for almost 5 years . the last time she gave a perfect vocal performance of a hard song to sing was during the 2001 telethon with the most amazing rendition ever to GOD BLESS AMERICA .

 

since then she mostly sings live easy songs with one note here and there...this is the first time in all of those years that she is going to sing live a very hard song - that's why i'm so excited and that's why i want it to be perfect cause i know the next time we'll have the chance to hear her nail notes like this will be around 2015

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Not quite. It's up to you how you define "nailing a performance". To me she nails every single songs she performs with "Brule Pas Tes Doigts" and "Destin" being the best examples.

 

It would be more appropriate to say she hasn't performed the Blues for 5 years now...

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

u know exactly what i mean - she didnt hit those long powerful notes that last 20 seconds each ...i miss it .

she didnt sing blues she didnt sing ABM and other huge hits that people love and would do anything to hear again live

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

 

No ! you love these huge notes... to prove that: everybody here say that she screams and not sings.

[Céline's Blues]

u know exactly what i mean - she didnt hit those long powerful notes that last 20 seconds each ...i miss it .

she didnt sing blues she didnt sing ABM and other huge hits that people love and would do anything to hear again live

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I don't think she'll be performing ABM anytime soon. She seems to dislike this song now. Her performances of I Surrender were pretty good if you like big notes and no they were not playback, at least not the majority.

 

And it's highly relative what ppl want... Céline herself was said asked about jazz album and intimate shows: "Why didn't I know that my fans want me to do this!?". That is the saddest thing actually.

[thevoice]

after tonight there will be no more questions about her voice - this is the first time in years that we r going to hear celine singing a very hard song (one of her hardest) 100% live - it's risky and if she did it she probably knew she could

 

You make the situation so dramatic!!! So exagerated!!!

She told herself she wasn't in a good shape that night due to the time difference :she had not slept a lot and she was tired.

Her voice changes every single day! Come on...

 

I'm sure it will be crap and then you will be the first to complain about it even if you KNOW NOW it won't be so good as before!

 

 

we didnt hear celine nail it big time like she used to for almost 5 years . the last time she gave a perfect vocal performance of a hard song to sing was during the 2001 telethon with the most amazing rendition ever to GOD BLESS AMERICA .

 

since then she mostly sings live easy songs with one note here and there...this is the first time in all of those years that she is going to sing live a very hard song - that's why i'm so excited and that's why i want it to be perfect cause i know the next time we'll have the chance to hear her nail notes like this will be around 2015

 

And I surrender?... even if in Vegas it's not live she had to sing it live at least once because it's not the same version of the cd.

And "aren't they all our children"? And "L'envie"?

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

IS is not live!! just the final notes . and recording it in the studio is not a problem . i know celine can hit all the notes in the studio - i want her to hit the notes live : end of discussion

 

and her voice in lenvie was raw eventho it was a great performance , she didnt hit those notes with a clear and powerful voice .

[thevoice]

u know exactly what i mean - she didnt hit those long powerful notes that last 20 seconds each ...i miss it .

she didnt sing blues she didnt sing ABM and other huge hits that people love and would do anything to hear again live

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

 

Céline herself was said asked about jazz album and intimate shows: "Why didn't I know that my fans want me to do this!?". That is the saddest thing actually.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

that's because most of her fans DO NOT want a jazz album .

most of the 30 million who bought FIY or LTAL want those mainstream powerful ballads . for her soul she can do whatever she wants to but if she wants commercial success it's not gonna work . so it's not that "her fans want a jazz album" it's more like YOU! and you paid jenna so she'll ask celine abou it lol!

Edited December 29, 2005 at 11:45 AM by thevoice

[Céline's Blues]

Nope, on "I surrender" she most definitely rotates the playback. There are MANY fans who can say when she was playbacking and when she sang this very song fully live. Apart from that she sang it live on the opening night.

[Céline's Blues]

that's because most of her fans DO NOT want a jazz album .

most of the 30 million who bought FIY or LTAL want those mainstream powerful ballads . for her soul she can do whatever she wants to but if she wants commercial success it's not gonna work . so it's not that "her fans want a jazz album" it's more like YOU! and you paid jenna so she'll ask celine abou it lol!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The most important thing is she KNOWS it now and will definitely do something in the right direction.

[thevoice]

Nope, on "I surrender" she most definitely rotates the playback. There are MANY fans who can say when she was playbacking and when she sang this very song fully live. Apart from that she sang it live on the opening night.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

1 - those "fans" r SCF's . i'll believe celine is an alien before i'll believe them .

 

2 - celine sang IS in playback on opening night and each and every night since then...it all sounds the same...i heard 7 diffrent performances and it's all the same . she opens the mic only when she gets to the RIGHT HERE RIGHT NOW part . - now that's a fact .

[thevoice]

that's because most of her fans DO NOT want a jazz album .

most of the 30 million who bought FIY or LTAL want those mainstream powerful ballads . for her soul she can do whatever she wants to but if she wants commercial success it's not gonna work . so it's not that "her fans want a jazz album" it's more like YOU! and you paid jenna so she'll ask celine abou it lol!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

The most important thing is she KNOWS it now and will definitely do something in the right direction.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

dont expect too much , sony will never let her do it so u too have to pray she'll leave sony as soon as possible

[Céline's Blues]

Nope, on "I surrender" she most definitely rotates the playback. There are MANY fans who can say when she was playbacking and when she sang this very song fully live. Apart from that she sang it live on the opening night.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

1 - those "fans" r SCF's . i'll believe celine is an alien before i'll believe them .

 

2 - celine sang IS in playback on opening night and each and every night since then...it all sounds the same...i heard 7 diffrent performances and it's all the same . she opens the mic only when she gets to the RIGHT HERE RIGHT NOW part . - now that's a fact .

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I don't think they are all SCFs. I don't deny she lips it but I am fairly certain she sings it live sometimes, as well. Fully live.

Edited December 29, 2005 at 11:51 AM by siur

[Céline's Blues]

dont expect too much , sony will never let her do it so u too have to pray she'll leave sony as soon as possible

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Don't forget JJG is at Sony as well. Aaaand the fact that Andy doesn't give a damn about Céline anymore. So she fades away as commercially irrelevant. That leaves up plenty of space for let's say...jazz?

[thevoice]

Nope, on "I surrender" she most definitely rotates the playback. There are MANY fans who can say when she was playbacking and when she sang this very song fully live. Apart from that she sang it live on the opening night.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

1 - those "fans" r SCF's . i'll believe celine is an alien before i'll believe them .

 

2 - celine sang IS in playback on opening night and each and every night since then...it all sounds the same...i heard 7 diffrent performances and it's all the same . she opens the mic only when she gets to the RIGHT HERE RIGHT NOW part . - now that's a fact .

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I don't think they are all SCFs. I don't deny she lips it but I am fairly certain she sings it live sometimes, as well. Fully live.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

she is not singing it live at all . u give her too much credit - why would she even bother ?? she is not changing anything in this show for the last 3 years almost , she couldnt care less ...she never sang any of the songs she sings in playback live...she couldnt even care enough to change the pre recorded version from time to time so people wont suspect . the list of the songs she sings in playback r well known , and nothing has changed .

this show is the biggest joke on earth...and if the critics only knew what's going on there , believe me this show couldnt last long , not like this .

[Céline's Blues]

she is not singing it live at all . u give her too much credit - why would she even bother ?? she is not changing anything in this show for the last 3 years almost , she couldnt care less ...she never sang any of the songs she sings in playback live...she couldnt even care enough to change the pre recorded version from time to time so people wont suspect . the list of the songs she sings in playback r well known , and nothing has changed .

this show is the biggest joke on earth...and if the critics only knew what's going on there , believe me this show couldnt last long , not like this .

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think the show is just fine for what it is and it isn't carried by the approval of the critics but by the masses and sold out audiences. Word of mouth is what helped Céline to sell throughout time. she is well worth it.

[Paulinha Dion]

wow man!!!! that recording must be awesome!!!!!!!!!!!

[thevoice]

she is not singing it live at all . u give her too much credit - why would she even bother ?? she is not changing anything in this show for the last 3 years almost , she couldnt care less ...she never sang any of the songs she sings in playback live...she couldnt even care enough to change the pre recorded version from time to time so people wont suspect . the list of the songs she sings in playback r well known , and nothing has changed .

this show is the biggest joke on earth...and if the critics only knew what's going on there , believe me this show couldnt last long , not like this .

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think the show is just fine for what it is and it isn't carried by the approval of the critics but by the masses and sold out audiences. Word of mouth is what helped Céline to sell throughout time. she is well worth it.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

she is worth it , but not her show . and believe me if people would know that she isnt singing live all her classics most of them wont pay so much to see this show .

ohhhh the power of manipulation

[Céline's Blues]

she is worth it , but not her show . and believe me if people would know that she isnt singing live all her classics most of them wont pay so much to see this show .

ohhhh the power of manipulation

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

You can't prove it to those 15,000 ppl/week. They enjoy the show immesely. There is no "IF". If this and that Céline would sing jazz now. If this and that Céline would be having a no. 1 in the US now with Snoop Dogg. May "IFs" come to my mind now.

[thevoice]

we r way off topic so i'm not gonna talk about it anymore...lets agree to disagree

[firebird]

Ladies, who cares if I Surrender is live? It's all about Le Blues Du Businessman - and she'll sing it live with a Symphonic Orchestra. That's a once in a lifetime experience (unfortunately, in my opinion she should do it more often).

[Céline's Blues]

Ladies, who cares if I Surrender is live? It's all about Le Blues Du Businessman - and she'll sing it live with a Symphonic Orchestra.  That's a once in a lifetime experience (unfortunately, in my opinion she should do it more often).

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Yepp...I can't turly CANT imagine how it'll sound with a real orchestra. Surely as orgasmic as her orchestral performance of LAEE back in 1992. But I don't think she should sing Le Blues more often...it's this kind of special song/performance that will be apricated for years to come.

[firebird]

But I don't think she should sing Le Blues more often...

Me neither, but she should perform live with an orchestra more often.

[thevoice]

she should sing this song atleast once a week

 

only 7 hours guys!!!!!!!!

do we know if she'll start the show or end it??

[Céline's Blues]

But I don't think she should sing Le Blues more often...

Me neither, but she should perform live with an orchestra more often.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Oh, yes, yes... that's for sure. First jazz, secondly orvchestra, thirdly electronica a la Björk.

 

After reading the comments on her future plans in the newest biography I'm certain the best is yet to come.

[isurrender]

She had to sing I surrender LIVE at least once!!!

 

Some posts I've read are... ridiculous!

[thevoice]

She had to sing I surrender LIVE at least once!!! 

 

Some posts I've read are... ridiculous! 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

u right , she sang it "live" in the studio only once and since then she is performing that pre recorded version night after night in vegas

[isurrender]

She had to sing I surrender LIVE at least once!!! 

 

Some posts I've read are... ridiculous! 

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

u right , she sang it "live" in the studio only once and since then she is performing that pre recorded version night after night in vegas

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

 

 

u didn't understand: this is a live pre recorded version...

 

 

Well, think what u want... I don't care !