Bonnie Tyler VS Tina Turner ''The Best''

[GoldenLeaf]

My favorite is Bonnie's version. It sounds vocally better, more passionate and more ''rockish'' than Tina's version.

 

Which version is your favorite and why ?

 

Edited June 15, 2008 at 10:42 PM by Calypso

[Black Kitten]

Bonnie Tyler all the way! can't stand Tina...

[GoldenLeaf]

Bonnie Tyler all the way! can't stand Tina...

I can't stand Tina either.

[destin139]

i voted bonnie tyler too, but it seems we are in the minority?!

[zoea2812]

I voted for Tina as I feel that Bonnie doesnt have a very nice voice. She just seems to croak her way through songs. Sorry.

[I Surrender]

Tina all the way

[Nikosn17]

Tina Turner all the way.

[WaterFromTheMoon]

I didn't even know that Bonnie sang it *lol*

I like both versions

[Snowhite]

My favourite version is Celine's version!!!!haha.She sang it incredible at Les stars de l'anee show!

[Esty]

Definitely Tina!!! Bonnie Tyler's voice annoys me so much.

[GoldenLeaf]

i voted bonnie tyler too, but it seems we are in the minority?!

Yeah, that's really weird! I thought we'd be in majority!

 

I voted for Tina as I feel that Bonnie doesn't have a very nice voice. She just seems to croak her way through songs. Sorry.

Don't me wrong but I think Tina's voice is worser! She has a three-tiered voice, with a nasal low register, a yowling, cutting middle range and a high register so it make her voice sounding like a falsetto.. and that's pretty annoying to hear.

Of course Bonnie doesn't have a perfect voice but in my opinion she sounds way better than Tina!

Edited June 19, 2008 at 10:01 PM by Calypso

[CelineRox]

Tina of course! I can't stand Bonnie Tyler

[Polar Star]

Definitely Bonnie for me, every time!!!!

I've seen Bonnie Tyler in concert many times and she is Amazing!!!! A Fantastic and unique voice!!!!!

[A New Day Has Come]

I say Tina Turner But I much prefer Celines version all the way.

[ThisTime]

I haven't heard Bonnie's but I would vote Celine if I could lol

[Soloni]

I haven't heard Bonnie's but I would vote Celine if I could lol

yeah i would too

 

But since i cant im chosing bonnie tylers version...

[celinebigfan]

TINAAAAAAAAAAA

 

By the way, anybody is plannig to see her in concert this year I've got ticktes for her concert in Atlanta. It might be the last time we see Tina live.

Edited July 2, 2008 at 04:20 AM by celinebigfan