Jump to content

Clarification about Céline's rehashing/cover songs


Recommended Posts

Posted

Falling Into You:

 

IACBTM = cover

FIY= cover

RDMH = Cover

I don't know = song raped by her without mercy, cover

If that's what it tales = see above

Fly = see above above

ABM = cover

Natural Woman = cover

16 songs on the CD = 50% covers/rehashed songs

 

TAST = almost all covers, one true rehashed song Brahm's Lullaby recorded in 1996, but it's an Xmas collection so it's forgivable

 

. Adeste Fideles

. O Holy Night

. Ave Maria

. Blue Christmas

. Brahm's Lullaby

. Les Cloches Du Hameau

. The Christmas Song

. Happy Christmas (War Is Over)

. Feliz Navidad

 

LET'S TALK ABOUT LOVE:

 

. I Hate You Then I Love You

. Amar Haciendo El Amor

. When I Need You

. Treat Her Like A Lady

. Love Is On The Way

. Let's Talk About Love

. Just A Little Bit Of Love

 

7 covers from 16 songs = 57% covers

 

ANDHC:

 

Ten Days

The Greatest Reward

Nature Boy

At Last

Aun Existe Amor

 

 

5 songs from 17 = 29% covers

 

OH

 

90% songs from ANDHC and its recording sessions :mdr: :mdr: :mdr: :mdr:

= 100% cover/rehashed LOL

 

Miracle:

 

Beautiful Boy

Brahm's Lullaby

If I Could

What A Wonderful World

The Prayer

The First Time

Une Chanson Douce

 

7 covers from 13 = 53% covers

http://i.imgur.com/dmreJ.jpg

Posted

but they are better..

why you said that OH is almost all covered... there's nothing except 2 song from ANDHC

A New Day... 10th & 11th November 2006 Taking Chances World Tour, Antwerp 13th & 14th May 2008, Kraków 28th June 2008 Celine 25th & 27th & 31st August 2013 20th, 23rd, 24th, 27th & 28th September 2016 Sans attendre Tour, Paris 1st & 5th December 2013 Encore un soir, Paris 24th, 25th, 28th, 29th June & 2nd, 3rd, 6th, 7th, 9th July 2016 Live 2017 Stockholm 17th June 2017 Lille 1st & 2nd July 2017 Paris 8th & 9th July 2017 Berlin 23rd & 24th July 2017 Live 2018 Taipei 11th & 13th July 2018 Manila 19th July 2018 Bangkok 23rd July 2018 BST Hyde Park London 5 July 2019 Paris 12th September 2nd and 3rd October 2026

Posted

There is a rumour she used some of the 26 songs recorded for ANDHC for OH.

 

CWS was also from ANDHC. Also a rehash.

http://i.imgur.com/dmreJ.jpg

Posted

JALBOL from LTAL a cover? from who!?

 

Wonder wich songs from ANDHC she used for OH, we know HYEBIL, SFL, CWS...

if she is planning to release them on a other album , why not just give us a 2cd pack of all recorded songs :P

Posted

so what's your point seb?

celine is not writing her songs anyway so noone cares about her covering songs , she is doing it much better than the original.

Posted
I posted it cuzz not everyone is aware of the continious use of covers. :P Mirage, I have no idea who the singers were, I took the info from queenceline.
http://i.imgur.com/dmreJ.jpg

Posted
There is a rumour she used some of the 26 songs recorded for ANDHC for OH

 

Like you said, it was only a rumour... she only recorded the songs we have on ANDHC. Plus All because of you and Coulda woulda shoulda.

This rumour comes from a little stupid french book called "Céline from A to Z" where we can read that she recorded 70 songs for A new day has come and that One heart was filled with that session! This book has so much errors on Céline's career and projects ! So don't trust it !

 

At the beginning , CWS was supposed to be on the original edition instead of "Ten days".

 

Then she fell in love with "Tomber" (french version of Ten days) while watching a french show and she wanted to record it in english. At that time, the album was finished !

 

Concerning Miracle... when the album was released , she said that the song "Miracle" was supposed to be on "One heart". But we don't know when she recorded it : was it during the recording of OH or Miracle?

 

And yes Just a little bit of love is a cover. I have the original one sung by Maria Christensen. This is exactly the same version! :D

Posted
so what's your point seb?

celine is not writing her songs anyway so noone cares about her covering songs , she is doing it much better than the original.

 

 

You're right!

They're much better! :D

Posted
I also found out that Hymne à l'amitié is a cover. Does anybody know if Mamy blue is a cover too, because i know that there are also others who sing it
Posted
Hymne a l'amitie was sung by Edith Piaf.
Posted

You forgot Des Mots Qui Sonnent : 4 original songs, 8 covers -> 66% covers

 

Concerning Miracle... when the album was released , she said that the song "Miracle" was supposed to be on "One heart". But we don't know when she recorded it : was it during the recording of OH or Miracle?

It was supposed to be on A New Day Has Come. The song was given to Celine in 2001 as a present for Rene Charles birth by Linda Thompson (David Foster's wife). I think she recorded it only for Miracle.

Posted
Yes, she recorded in 2004, at the begining of the year, when she did the other songs and the photo session with Anne. :wub:
Posted
I also found out that Hymne à l'amitié is a cover. Does anybody know if Mamy blue is a cover too, because i know that there are also others who sing it

 

Hymne a l'amitie was sung by Edith Piaf.

 

Edith Piaf sung "Hymne à l'amour" not "Hymne à l'amitié".

 

But Hymne à l'amitié is a cover too! Originally, it's an english song !

 

And yes, Mamy Blue is a cover !

Posted (edited)

À quatre Pas d'ici is also a cover, from Land of makebelieve... an all most all her french x-mas albums are covers too...

 

I don't care Céline covers that much... her versions are usually better! :D

 

and Seb.... you forgot 1f4t.... Tu nages, Rien n'est vraiment fini and Retiens-moi are also covers! 25% covers!!! WITH JJ'S APPROVAL!! :shocked: :P

Edited by Davey84


Rick, ik hou van jou voor altijd!



A New Day... has come 28/29 April & 2/3 May 07



Antwerpen 13 et 14 mai,Paris 24 et 25 mai, Amsterdam 2 juinet Arras 7 juillet Chances Taken!!!



How Do You Keep The Music Playing? - Celine Opening Night March 15th, March 16th

Posted
I don't care Céline covers that much

Yes, the only thing I care is when they put one song on different albums like Have You Ever Been In Love or The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face, and actually sometimes the old songs are better then the ones especially written for an album. I mean for example if you take The Power Of Love is certainly better than Real Emotion or The Greatest Reward (old) :thumbsup2: and Rain, Tax (new) :thumbdown:

Posted
I don't care Céline covers that much

Yes, the only thing I care is when they put one song on different albums like Have You Ever Been In Love or The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face, and actually sometimes the old songs are better then the ones especially written for an album. I mean for example if you take The Power Of Love is certainly better than Real Emotion or The Greatest Reward (old) :thumbsup2: and Rain, Tax (new) :thumbdown:

 

yeah you're so right! well I like Rain tax :kicking: :giggle: :lmao: but somettimes the covers are better then the 'new' songs... and I hate the fact that a few songs keep getting recycled! :glare:


Rick, ik hou van jou voor altijd!



A New Day... has come 28/29 April & 2/3 May 07



Antwerpen 13 et 14 mai,Paris 24 et 25 mai, Amsterdam 2 juinet Arras 7 juillet Chances Taken!!!



How Do You Keep The Music Playing? - Celine Opening Night March 15th, March 16th

Posted

It's true that Celine covers many songs, which is not so great... I thinks she could write or someone could write her equally good NEW songs... However, we must keep in mind that her covers are usually better than the originals (TPOL, IYAMT) and certainly more famous (IACBTMN) and people usually connect these songs with Celine...

In general, I don't mind covers... but keep the quota of 1 or 2 at most, cover song maximally on an album...

Posted

The thing is..who cares that they are "leftovers" from a previous album..the songs are still new to us. We never heard them.

 

The one thing that this shows us, is that this was done even before OH. So it's nothing new.

»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»»» MATHIAS ««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NzPrxI0AIDY

Posted

Are you guys saying that you would prefer it if once a song has been recorded, NO-ONE should EVER record that song again? Imagine if you were a song writer, maybe a musical genius who's not so hot at singing, but amazing at composing contemporary, chart-worthy material. If one person had recorded your song, and it remained an album filler and hardly enyone ever heard it, you would have NO chance of anyone ever hearing it again, because no-one else would be able to use it.

 

I know I'm taking it to the extreme here, but most song writers write songs for singers sing! Not just once, but many times! There are many artists that don't write their own material, but give a unique take on someone elses. It's like remaking a movie, sometimes it's better, sometimes it's not. But if it's good story it should be told and told again, a good song should be sung!

 

Song writers BEG Celine to sing their songs! Even if people have sang them before her! Because she has a talent for making songs her own and giving them her magical touch, I wouldn't ever want her to stop.

 

Love Lisa

xxx

Posted
Are you guys saying that you would prefer it if once a song has been recorded, NO-ONE should EVER record that song again? Imagine if you were a song writer, maybe a musical genius who's not so hot at singing, but amazing at composing contemporary, chart-worthy material. If one person had recorded your song, and it remained an album filler and hardly enyone ever heard it, you would have NO chance of anyone ever hearing it again, because no-one else would be able to use it.

 

I know I'm taking it to the extreme here, but most song writers write songs for singers sing! Not just once, but many times! There are many artists that don't write their own material, but give a unique take on someone elses. It's like remaking a movie, sometimes it's better, sometimes it's not. But if it's good story it should be told and told again, a good song should be sung!

 

Song writers BEG Celine to sing their songs! Even if people have sang them before her! Because she has a talent for making songs her own and giving them her magical touch, I  wouldn't ever want her to stop.

 

Love Lisa

xxx

 

I think that people here don't mean that Celine shouldn't cover any song ever, but rather that she doesn't overdo recording covers...

Posted

I have no problem with Celine recording "covers"....people are now recording original Celine Dion songs! Anyway, Celine's recordings are always superior to previous releases.

 

However, I do have a problem with the One Heart album. There are songs on their from A New Day Has Come and one from All The Way sessions. Not to mention that there's a song on there recorded when Celine was sick...and the rest were thrown together in a short period of time. It's not a solid album, and I wish that they would have just not released it and spent more time promoting A New Day Has Come, which is a solid album.

 

As far as Miracle, it is also thrown together....however it has a solid theme with many more tracks recorded just for this album. Also, it was never meant to appeal to the general public.

Posted

Siur (Seb),

can you tell who sang before Amar Haciendo El Amor and Just A Little Bit Of Love? I didn't know they were covers... :w00t:

Posted
Siur (Seb),

can you tell who sang before Amar Haciendo El Amor and Just A Little Bit Of Love? I didn't know they were covers... :w00t:

Just A Little Bit Of Love was sung by the singer isurrender mentioned above in his post. :) And Amar Haciendo I have NO idea! It was on the list of her cover sngs on www.queenceline.com! :) But as far as I can remember it was an acoustic singer.

http://i.imgur.com/dmreJ.jpg

Posted
so what's your point seb?

celine is not writing her songs anyway so noone cares about her covering songs , she is doing it much better than the original.

 

 

 

 

:clap: :clap: :clap: way much better!!!

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-WTOLnq_3hiM/T-YMZXaW9JI/AAAAAAAACR4/bCmTbbqNEhY/s400/Celine+Dion+-+Signature+Commercial+Behind+The+Scenes+(23612)+%5BHD%5D.mp4_snapshot_00.20_%5B2012.06.22_00.44.23%5D.jpg

I dOn'T sUfFer FrOm InSaNiTy...I eNjOy EvErY MiNuTe Of iT...

 

Posted
I have it, maxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx! The original is titled "You Only Love Once" by Billy Mann. :bye1:
http://i.imgur.com/dmreJ.jpg

Posted
I have it, maxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx! The original is titled "You Only Love Once" by Billy Mann. :bye1:

 

thanks Seb :flowers: , do you know the year he recorded his version?

Posted (edited)

No idea when he recorded it. It was released on his self-titled album in 1996.

[link]

Edited by solaris
Posted

Unison has 3 covers ! ===>33,333333%

 

The last to know

Unison

Have a heart !

 

:D

Posted
I also found out that Hymne à l'amitié is a cover. Does anybody know if Mamy blue is a cover too, because i know that there are also others who sing it

 

Hymne a l'amitie was sung by Edith Piaf.

 

Edith Piaf sung "Hymne à l'amour" not "Hymne à l'amitié".

 

But Hymne à l'amitié is a cover too! Originally, it's an english song !

 

And yes, Mamy Blue is a cover !

 

 

 

Do you know from whom is the original Mamy blue?

 

I forgot the last time to say that Hymne à l'amitié is a cover of the italian song Amico è .

 

http://cover6.cduniverse.com/MuzeAudioArt/570/573673.jpg Amico è 1982 - D.Baldan Bembo

Posted
I have no problem with Celine recording "covers"....people are now recording original Celine Dion songs! Anyway, Celine's recordings are always superior to previous releases.

 

However, I do have a problem with the One Heart album. There are songs on their from A New Day Has Come and one from All The Way sessions. Not to mention that there's a song on there recorded when Celine was sick...and the rest were thrown together in a short period of time. It's not a solid album, and I wish that they would have just not released it and spent more time promoting A New Day Has Come, which is a solid album.

 

As far as Miracle, it is also thrown together....however it has a solid theme with many more tracks recorded just for this album. Also, it was never meant to appeal to the general public.

 

Which song off of OH was from the ATW sessions?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...