777 replies to this topic

[simon2004]

Today is "a new day", so we're waiting for new videos, especially "all by myself"   
thanks again for the previous videos

[mirage]

the 3rd show changes:

Another small adjustment, each time the singer was to go to change, the scene was plunged one moment in the darkness. And one had less the impression that the eight dancers were in the legs of the musicians and Celine, even if their contribution is probably appreciated with its right value only on the central scene.

[anewdayhascome]

it was in Durban?
Can anybody tell me if our hero has the video for the whole concert? because if yes i won't download the whole thing i'll leave for myself to discover

[CSCfan]

No, 2nd Pretoria gig..

[hutz13]

I found a couple of new videos have been added since yesterday at this site but it doesn't say if they are from 1st or 2nd Pretoria show ... I guess it doesn't matter that much.


It looks like Jane has provided the best video coverage to us here.

[CSCfan]

They're Jane's video's....  and the intro vid is posted twice. Plus, the setlist for the 2nd Pretoria gig doesn't match..

[scorp82]

Sergey, on Feb 20 2008, 03:25 AM, said:

You know, there's one thing, which I simply refuse to understand - why does Celine cheat with The power of love in such a rude way?
I mean, every Celine's fan, who has heard to many, many of her live performances and who perfectly knows her album version, can easily say that in this latest concert bootleg of The power of love, Celine does the same thing she had been doing in Las Vegas shows - she sings the first verse live and then starting from the first chorus ('cause I'm your lady... and till the end of this song) we hear the Colour of my love studio recording played back.
I mean, you can instantly hear the dramatic change in her voice between her having sung the whispers in the morning... LIVE, HERE and NOW, and what comes next when the playback studio recording begins - that voice of 15 (!) years back.

Wasn't it easier to record some recent FULL LIVE version of this song and lipping this recent pre-recorded The power of love instead of this weird mixture of live+studio?  

Sergey, please check your private messages.

Thank you.

[JP]

Since i had no supporters at all, i've just watch everything LOL
For her voice she sounds so great but for the show, i must say i can't wait for her central stage!

[CelineFanInSoCal]

scorp82, on Feb 20 2008, 09:14 AM, said:

Sergey, on Feb 20 2008, 03:25 AM, said:

You know, there's one thing, which I simply refuse to understand - why does Celine cheat with The power of love in such a rude way?
I mean, every Celine's fan, who has heard to many, many of her live performances and who perfectly knows her album version, can easily say that in this latest concert bootleg of The power of love, Celine does the same thing she had been doing in Las Vegas shows - she sings the first verse live and then starting from the first chorus ('cause I'm your lady... and till the end of this song) we hear the Colour of my love studio recording played back.
I mean, you can instantly hear the dramatic change in her voice between her having sung the whispers in the morning... LIVE, HERE and NOW, and what comes next when the playback studio recording begins - that voice of 15 (!) years back.

Wasn't it easier to record some recent FULL LIVE version of this song and lipping this recent pre-recorded The power of love instead of this weird mixture of live+studio?  

Sergey, please check your private messages.

Thank you.

Get anything good?  LOL  j/k

[CelineFanInSoCal]

JP, on Feb 20 2008, 10:09 AM, said:

Since i had no supporters at all, i've just watch everything LOL
For her voice she sounds so great but for the show, i must say i can't wait for her central stage!

Me too!  From the clips I've seen so far, it looks live everything is cramped into a small stage and it almost looks boring [maybe because i know there's going to be a bigger production down the road].

I am thrilled just thinking about what the show will hopefully evolve to...  I've heard some pretty cool rumors...

[celbabs]

Sergey, on Feb 20 2008, 03:25 AM, said:

You know, there's one thing, which I simply refuse to understand - why does Celine cheat with The power of love in such a rude way?
I mean, every Celine's fan, who has heard to many, many of her live performances and who perfectly knows her album version, can easily say that in this latest concert bootleg of The power of love, Celine does the same thing she had been doing in Las Vegas shows - she sings the first verse live and then starting from the first chorus ('cause I'm your lady... and till the end of this song) we hear the Colour of my love studio recording played back.
I mean, you can instantly hear the dramatic change in her voice between her having sung the whispers in the morning... LIVE, HERE and NOW, and what comes next when the playback studio recording begins - that voice of 15 (!) years back.

Wasn't it easier to record some recent FULL LIVE version of this song and lipping this recent pre-recorded The power of love instead of this weird mixture of live+studio?  

I have just seen the clip and was coming on here to post the same thing.  I have been a big fan of Celine since 1991 when someone bought me her 2nd English album, Celine Dion (which is why I'm so glad she continues to do Love Can Move Mountains in concert - it's always been one of my faves and has connections for me dating back to college) and I must say that I don't necessarily mind that she's lip-synching a bit these days.  She is almost 40 after all and, being a singer myself, I know that your voice changes over time.  But it is DEFINITELY obvious that after the first verse it switches to the album track.  I wish they would just lower the key instead though like they did for All By Myself, My Heart Will Go On and I Surrender (each has been a half a step lower than the album track since she started doing them live - a very normal occurance for singers to do when singing live).

Also, after watching the clip of Taking Chances, I'm pretty sure it switches to the album track right before the big note on "Whaddaya SAY to jumping off the edge".  From there on it, it's the track (or at least until it goes back down into her lower register).  They try to hide it by having the backup singers get REALLY loud.

[CelinesDIVO5]

celbabs, on Feb 20 2008, 06:36 PM, said:

Sergey, on Feb 20 2008, 03:25 AM, said:

You know, there's one thing, which I simply refuse to understand - why does Celine cheat with The power of love in such a rude way?
I mean, every Celine's fan, who has heard to many, many of her live performances and who perfectly knows her album version, can easily say that in this latest concert bootleg of The power of love, Celine does the same thing she had been doing in Las Vegas shows - she sings the first verse live and then starting from the first chorus ('cause I'm your lady... and till the end of this song) we hear the Colour of my love studio recording played back.
I mean, you can instantly hear the dramatic change in her voice between her having sung the whispers in the morning... LIVE, HERE and NOW, and what comes next when the playback studio recording begins - that voice of 15 (!) years back.

Wasn't it easier to record some recent FULL LIVE version of this song and lipping this recent pre-recorded The power of love instead of this weird mixture of live+studio?  

I have just seen the clip and was coming on here to post the same thing.  I have been a big fan of Celine since 1991 when someone bought me her 2nd English album, Celine Dion (which is why I'm so glad she continues to do Love Can Move Mountains in concert - it's always been one of my faves and has connections for me dating back to college) and I must say that I don't necessarily mind that she's lip-synching a bit these days.  She is almost 40 after all and, being a singer myself, I know that your voice changes over time.  But it is DEFINITELY obvious that after the first verse it switches to the album track.  I wish they would just lower the key instead though like they did for All By Myself, My Heart Will Go On and I Surrender (each has been a half a step lower than the album track since she started doing them live - a very normal occurance for singers to do when singing live).

Also, after watching the clip of Taking Chances, I'm pretty sure it switches to the album track right before the big note on "Whaddaya SAY to jumping off the edge".  From there on it, it's the track (or at least until it goes back down into her lower register).  They try to hide it by having the backup singers get REALLY loud.

if you listen, it's not TCOML version...the live version is pre-recorded and taken down either a half step or full step..it's lower in tone, just listen to it...they can't have Celine start the song in one key with live vocals and then have it be a completely different key throughout the rest of the song..and it's not.....not only did we have complaints about when she lipsynchs..but now you are creating a new monster by saying she's using the album tracks for certain parts of the songs..that's a little insane..get over yourselves and just enjoy it

Edited by CelinesDIVO5, 20 February 2008 - 05:44 PM.

[Ororo Munroe]

simon2004, on Feb 20 2008, 07:19 AM, said:

Today is "a new day", so we're waiting for new videos, especially "all by myself"   
thanks again for the previous videos

Please - I want so much to see all by myself, I can't wait, GOOD JOB  

[celbabs]

Well, I've listened to The Power Of Love version off of The Colour of My Love album over the past 13 years about oh 1,000 times I would say.  I have lip-synched to it myself at least a couple hundred.      I know that it is the same track.  

Now, going back and watching the clip again (because I'm fascinated over exactly where the switch is and what it is), I agree with you.  This last time I watched it I thought, at the beginning, that sounds a half a step lower when she's singing it live.  However, being in the music business, I also know that it's extremely easy to lower a track by half a step or more or to raise it.  Hello, even in Kareoke clubs they can change the track that you're singing to by raising it or lowering it a step or two or 4.  

I don't get why people get bothered by the Celine lip-synching issue.  So many singers do it and GREAT ones at that.  It's a fact of the business.  It doesn't make her bad or less of a singer or any of that.  I still love her and always will.  When my heart was shattered to pieces the last time, I just couldn't listen to music much but Celine was the only music that I could still stomach (which is my roommate's make fun of me - for about 9 months I didn't listen to anything BUT her)  

[artistman2007]

olso its not about what they do in the music buisnes but maybe her voice chnged that there are parts and some notes that she cant reach them at all now so she lip sing them and thats alright

[Nando Férri]

Mmmm... Why the post of HUTZ13 was edited? Why someone took off the link?

[fab]

Sorry Bug

Edited by fab, 20 February 2008 - 07:29 PM.

[anget64]

did fade away ever load?

i think it was uploading to the website or something but did it go through?

[stagecraft]

MAAAAN...it's one thing to lip-synch something because you're doing a strenuous dance or there are reasons you couldn't do a proper soundcheck...but to lip-synch the high notes is just LAAAAAME. As a singer it is something i would never do! If you feel you can't sing them live, then don't perform those songs...in fact...if you can't do it live, don't even record those songs! I accept lip-synching for maybe one or two numbers in a show...but if Kylie Minogue can perform her whole 2 1/2 hour show live, i see no reason why Celine can't.

[anget64]

I AGREE

celine is known for her voice and for her to not sing those high notes......... is everyone sure she wasn't really singing them live?

[Loup_garou]

stagecraft, on Feb 20 2008, 09:42 PM, said:

MAAAAN...it's one thing to lip-synch something because you're doing a strenuous dance or there are reasons you couldn't do a proper soundcheck...but to lip-synch the high notes is just LAAAAAME. As a singer it is something i would never do! If you feel you can't sing them live, then don't perform those songs...in fact...if you can't do it live, don't even record those songs! I accept lip-synching for maybe one or two numbers in a show...but if Kylie Minogue can perform her whole 2 1/2 hour show live, i see no reason why Celine can't.

LOL!!!   This is getting way too funny ....another newbie with one post talking 'bout lyp-synch...the only thing missing is finishing the bashing with "i see no reason why CELION can't"....LOL  

this forum is getting seriously spammed

[hutz13]

Nando Férri, on Feb 20 2008, 08:15 PM, said:

Mmmm... Why the post of HUTZ13 was edited? Why someone took off the link?

I think it may be against forum rules tp post links to other sites, so I tried to add the site to my sig but that seemed to be foiled also but I see many other members with links to Celine blogs so I don't understand.

[Bellamy]

hutz13, on Feb 21 2008, 11:25 AM, said:

Nando Férri, on Feb 20 2008, 08:15 PM, said:

Mmmm... Why the post of HUTZ13 was edited? Why someone took off the link?

I think it may be against forum rules tp post links to other sites, so I tried to add the site to my sig but that seemed to be foiled also but I see many other members with links to Celine blogs so I don't understand.

Cause all that site did is copy Jane's bootleg videos and claim as theirs. Nothing new anyway.

[CelineFanInSoCal]

celbabs, on Feb 20 2008, 04:01 PM, said:

Well, I've listened to The Power Of Love version off of The Colour of My Love album over the past 13 years about oh 1,000 times I would say.  I have lip-synched to it myself at least a couple hundred.      I know that it is the same track.  

Now, going back and watching the clip again (because I'm fascinated over exactly where the switch is and what it is), I agree with you.  This last time I watched it I thought, at the beginning, that sounds a half a step lower when she's singing it live.  However, being in the music business, I also know that it's extremely easy to lower a track by half a step or more or to raise it.  Hello, even in Kareoke clubs they can change the track that you're singing to by raising it or lowering it a step or two or 4.  

I don't get why people get bothered by the Celine lip-synching issue.  So many singers do it and GREAT ones at that.  It's a fact of the business.  It doesn't make her bad or less of a singer or any of that.  I still love her and always will.  When my heart was shattered to pieces the last time, I just couldn't listen to music much but Celine was the only music that I could still stomach (which is my roommate's make fun of me - for about 9 months I didn't listen to anything BUT her)  

Ok, this whole thing about her lipping to the ALBUM version of any song during a world tour is kinda absurd.  We all can appreciate that you've listened to an album track so many times, though it's obvious that you haven't listened to the album track from "Live a Paris" or "A New Day..." DVD.  She's not switching from live to an album version of TPOL, nor of ANY song...  sure, she may lip to previous recorded live tracks, or "switch" back and forth, but not to an album version...  sheeessh!  I can dig the talks about lipping to other live tracks, but NOT the lipping to album versions on a world tour....  

[CelineFanInSoCal]

Loup_garou, on Feb 20 2008, 07:06 PM, said:

stagecraft, on Feb 20 2008, 09:42 PM, said:

MAAAAN...it's one thing to lip-synch something because you're doing a strenuous dance or there are reasons you couldn't do a proper soundcheck...but to lip-synch the high notes is just LAAAAAME. As a singer it is something i would never do! If you feel you can't sing them live, then don't perform those songs...in fact...if you can't do it live, don't even record those songs! I accept lip-synching for maybe one or two numbers in a show...but if Kylie Minogue can perform her whole 2 1/2 hour show live, i see no reason why Celine can't.

LOL!!!   This is getting way too funny ....another newbie with one post talking 'bout lyp-synch...the only thing missing is finishing the bashing with "i see no reason why CELION can't"....LOL  

this forum is getting seriously spammed

ha ha ha ha ha  so true!!!!  All singers and performers are different...  when Ms. Minoque decides to sing some more songs that require the use of her heart and soul and not endless pop dribble, then people can make comments like that.  But I like her stuff anyway....  LOL

[Duchess]

sorry i can't turn the pics around.

[stagecraft]

I don't think that's the argument here...what your opinion of the singer is...And i'm certainly not spamming this site, i've loved celine since i was 6. I was going to buy tickets but am i going to give that woman my money if she's going to be too lazy to sing those top notes! Because I know plenty of singers who perform in musical theatre 8 times a week who are required to perform far more difficult songs... It has nothing to do with preserving your voice or the songs being too difficult...if your technique is good enough (which i believe celine's is) you're voice won't tire from her schedule...this is why i feel it's laziness

[Sergey]

celbabs, on Feb 21 2008, 05:01 AM, said:

I don't get why people get bothered by the Celine lip-synching issue.  So many singers do it and GREAT ones at that.  It's a fact of the business.  It doesn't make her bad or less of a singer or any of that.  I still love her and always will.  When my heart was shattered to pieces the last time, I just couldn't listen to music much but Celine was the only music that I could still stomach (which is my roommate's make fun of me - for about 9 months I didn't listen to anything BUT her)  

I feel the same - I'm not bothered and I still love her and always will...
But lip-synch the whole song (or a couple during a show) if you need or wish, not part of it.  

Edited by Sergey, 21 February 2008 - 02:02 AM.

[stagecraft]

I have nothing against Celine and i still believe she's an amazing performer...but i wouldn't pay that much money to see anyone stand onstage miming to something which was recorded in the studio environment... I don't see what the point is...I'm not one who gets starstruck at just the sight of someone....

[Koolan]

Please no more talk about lipsync again, let's get back on topic. Thanks.