64 replies to this topic

[Bellamy]

siur, on May 21 2006, 01:40 AM, said:

My fav rendition of PQTME is the Vegas one AND the 1 Fille 4 Types special one - he duet version where she sounds more fragile than ever!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I'm   to this version.  

[Céline's Blues]

Bellamy, on May 20 2006, 01:37 PM, said:

siur, on May 21 2006, 01:40 AM, said:

My fav rendition of PQTME is the Vegas one AND the 1 Fille 4 Types special one - he duet version where she sounds more fragile than ever!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I'm   to this version.  

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

            

[Bellamy]

Cause Florent Pagny ruined the whole song.

[Paulinha Dion]

I liked it... Celine is the best one for sure, but she was good.

[Javier_Natalio]

how dares she...

Britney cannot sing X-tina, Larka cannot sing Celine!

I't like openly admitting she ever had a carreer just because Céline was there first to be imitated!

Edit: Which we already knew... but how dares she anyway, to mock us like that...

Edited by wacko.javo, 20 May 2006 - 06:26 PM.

[Paulinha Dion]

RRphantom, on May 20 2006, 11:49 AM, said:

I don't think it's bad.
At least it's better than Il Divo's

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I LIKE IL DIVO´S VERSION, IT´S STRONG!

[songbird]

I had already listened to an audio clip before, I think it's terrible and it has nothing to do with the actual song.

[anewdayhascome]

it's horrible and the copy!

[raluca]

well...to be honest with you...i simply love Lara's version of course Celine is the best of the best...but still...i think Lara didi a very good job!

[4celine]

Celinemaniac, on May 20 2006, 08:38 AM, said:

Guys, don't go wild! Celine is always Celine and we can also like other artists too! Lara Fabian is a great artist! She has admitted loving Celine and having her albums. If she's been compared to Celine many times, it's because of the kind of music she does, which sometimes is very close to Celine's style(power ballads, high notes etc). But, if you watch Lara's "En Toute Entimite" DVD, you will understand that there's a lot of differences. I think Lara chose Pour Que Tu M'Aimes Encore because it's among the classics of Celine's french songs. Her rendition had to be different because: 1) Lara didn't want to be compared to Celine for one more time (and so she seems trying hard to sing it in a completely different way) and 2) the concept of the show is more acoustic (that's why she's singing it only with a piano). I believe it was a good try anyway and also a way for Lara to show her love for Celine. Watch it with pure heart and no fanatism.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

THANK YOU i'm glad someone see the things clear here! Lara is a great singer as powerfull as celine they do the same kind of music because they have a voice for it! And Lara don't copy Celine; Lara works hard even more than celine she writte her music and lyrics,  her songs câme from her heart, celine just take what rené wants her to sing almost all the time

[4celine]

songbird, on May 21 2006, 03:28 AM, said:

I had already listened to an audio clip before, I think it's terrible and it has nothing to do with the actual song.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

it's different like when celine take songs from the others..

[HelenCeline27]

she is ok           

[firebird]

I like it. Maybe she sang the song, because she likes Céline's music? I mean that could also be a reason, no?!, not just because she wants to copy her ...  The whole concert is really good. I wish Celine did something like that : an acoustique concert tour   
I think it's rather an honour for Céline that other singer cover her songs.

[4celine]

solaris, on May 21 2006, 06:25 AM, said:

I like it. Maybe she sang the song, because she likes Céline's music? I mean that could also be a reason, no?!, not just because she wants to copy her ...  The whole concert is really good. I wish Celine did something like that : an acoustique concert tour   I think it's rather an honour for Céline that other singer cover her songs.

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Me tooo

[Bellamy]

4celine, on May 21 2006, 06:53 PM, said:

Lara works hard even more than celine she writte her music and lyrics,  her songs câme from her heart, celine just take what rené wants her to sing almost all the time

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Writes crappy songs to try to copy what JJG did, doesn't mean she works harder than Celine.  

[celinesolomia]

the performer of lara is    and celine is celine the only

[pepillo90]

Not bad  

but i prefer thousand times more the celine's version!


I think Lara don't put the emotions like Celine...


I hate IL DIVO's version  

[4celine]

Bellamy, on May 21 2006, 10:47 AM, said:

4celine, on May 21 2006, 06:53 PM, said:

Lara works hard even more than celine she writte her music and lyrics,  her songs câme from her heart, celine just take what rené wants her to sing almost all the time

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Writes crappy songs to try to copy what JJG did, doesn't mean she works harder than Celine.  

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

she do it herself, she don't take someone do do her songs...
Celine is my favourite voice but he must be reallistes she sings only, other people make more than her

[Celinemaniac]

4celine, on May 22 2006, 09:33 AM, said:

Bellamy, on May 21 2006, 10:47 AM, said:

4celine, on May 21 2006, 06:53 PM, said:

Lara works hard even more than celine she writte her music and lyrics,  her songs câme from her heart, celine just take what rené wants her to sing almost all the time

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Writes crappy songs to try to copy what JJG did, doesn't mean she works harder than Celine.  

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

she do it herself, she don't take someone do do her songs...
Celine is my favourite voice but he must be reallistes she sings only, other people make more than her

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Look, Celine doesn't write her songs but that doen't mean that she is less an artist! She "knows" music - she plays the piano very well, and she can write songs (she co-wrote Tout Pres Du Bonheur, Don't Save It All For Christmas Day, Ce N'Etait Qu'Un Reve...). As for her songs, she selects what to record - of course, some people offer her songs to choose from.
Lara does it almost all by herself and the result is completely hers. But as you may know, she needs to collaborate too (Jean-Felix Lalanne, Rick Allison).

Attached Files

•  portraitcroise4.jpg   10.45K   0 downloads
•  Lara002.jpe   23.57K   5 downloads

[4celine]

but she's realy good! i just want people to stop hurt lara...

[Annabelle]

so why did u give out the link LOL and not just made a description of th evideo ??  

[celdia_5]

Paulinha Dion, on May 21 2006, 05:01 AM, said:

RRphantom, on May 20 2006, 11:49 AM, said:

I don't think it's bad.
At least it's better than Il Divo's

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I LIKE IL DIVO´S VERSION, IT´S STRONG!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

i like it too,

[catwomanrrr]

I personally think Celine would be flattered by this performance.


IN a way, this performance is a "tribute to Celine" because it's the song that most French listeners associate with Celine. However, I think Lara turned this song into sort of a cabaret act because of the pauses and spoken words!    

Edited by Joy, 30 June 2006 - 11:49 PM.

[Mozinha]

Gosh that was awful. She looks like a corpse.

[Célinefull]

People always say Lara has so much emotion in her voice - I can hear it. Like her version of LBDB..Céline captured the emotions a hell of a lot better than Lara did..yet people always say "Oh she is so emotional!" Well I'm emotional all the time too, no one's offering me a record contract

[ahmed]

i love this version too

[puffa]

Okay, I admit she sang it very well ... she did her own style!!!


We don't have to judge her just because it's a Céline's rival or just because she is singing a Céline's song.



Of course all of us prefer Céline, with no doubt!!!!!!First-> she's our idol
Second-> she was the first person that sang this song, and it's stays on our mind
Third-> we know the meaning of this for Céline


Probably Lara Fabian sang it with no feeling ... I think it isn't the right expression ... let me explain this ...

probably Lara Fabian doesn't sang with the feeling that we are used to ... I think this make the difference!!


Kiss

PUFFA***

[Mozinha]

puffa, on Jul 1 2006, 12:07 PM, said:

probably Lara Fabian doesn't sang with the feeling that we are used to ... I think

That is why I never liked her. I feel no emotion whatsoever coming from her. It's like a corpse singing. Some people might think she has a lot of emotion but I can't honestly feel it.
Anyways, I don't like it. I didn't like the Il Divo version either. I loved them, I loved their albums but they murdered this song.

[Un Rêve]

It's actually really nice. It's no Céline and she doesn't sing it as passionately as Céline does, but she did a great job singing it her own way.

[celinerific]

Frightening. LOL!