237 replies to this topic

[celinesounds]

i believe  80% of males who like Celine are gay

[David & Goliath]

Céline Dion's fans are not gays, they are bisexual ! l0l

[Love,]

Someone had to dig this thread back up!

[JP]

Celine is for sure a Gay Icon.. But for sure, not every gay loves her, i know more gay people who don't like her than like her.. LOL

And btw, i'm gay lol

[alextrusca]

.And the male fans who say they ain't gay surely hide it and are in fact GAY...Come on, who cares if Celine's fans are gay or not?

[Leda]

Well, actually, this topic was discussed already. Personally I think that it's not really true. I know that A LOT of Madonna's male fans, as well as Mylene Farmer's male fans are gays - that's for sure. As fas as Celine is concerned... I know A LOT of Celine's male fans all over the world and no one is gay...

[GoldenLeaf]

That's a stupid question

I'm not gay and I love Celine

If you think that all Celine's fans men are gay, this means that you think Madonna's Father are gay because he is a Celine fan  

[Love,]

The question is.... what makes a person a "Fan"? To what degree?

There are some people who adore Celine, attends her concerts, but don't follow her every day.

There are those who adore her from a distance, buying one or two CDs, yet admiring her as an individual and singer.

There are those who are friends of Celine.

There are those who have friends who have been touched by Celine and admire her from a distance.

There are those who don't follow Celine at all, but enjoy listening to her music on the radio.

There are those who are fanatics who are members of a forum dedicated exclusively to her, knows all the facts and details about her, can tell the story of her life, attends her concerts, etc.

There are those who are absolute fanatics who are members of a forum dedicated exclusively to her, knows all the facts and details about her, can tell the story of her life, attends her concerts, eat, sleep, dream about Celine; cannot imagine a day without Celine in their life.

The "stalkers."

The list goes on...

[cdfan]

I don;t think it's any point in talking about that. Even if someone is gay does it matter to you?

[paradox]

David & Goliath, on Dec 22 2006, 02:28 AM, said:

Céline Dion's fans are not gays, they are bisexual ! l0l

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think bisexual are trendy ppl, they trying to copy gay ppl too to be cool  

[nico robin]

mazceline, on Jul 6 2006, 11:03 AM, said:

no i aint arguing, i think all walks of life love celine cause she is in one word AMAZING............

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

of course!!!!

bruno_oliveira, on Dec 21 2006, 10:38 PM, said:

hey
go to a cher concert and to a madonna's concert....
that is gay icon hehehe

i think is very rare to see a lot of drag queens at a celines concert

celine is more family - young couples - people willing to love...


propose too....

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

well celine might be what you say for family, young couples...but that doesn't mean gay ppl can't like celine... celine is for everybody who knows what great music is   i can't say that all gays love celine but...as i see many gays like/love celine...and so what we love her too!!
it doesn't matter if you're gay or not as long as you like celine is all cool hehe

David & Goliath, on Dec 22 2006, 01:28 AM, said:

Céline Dion's fans are not gays, they are bisexual ! l0l

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

[Celinemaniac]

I adore Celine and I'm not gay... I am a "sensitive" guy ,for sure, and that's maybe what my girlfriend likes in me... and all the girls I've met in my life so far, I suppose!

Haven't I the wright to adore Celine? Must I be "labeled"* about it or something?

And the fact is that many straight men do like her, and pretend not to like her!!!


* Being gay is not an "accusation", but since I'm not gay, this caracterisation can be very misleading for others about me!

[Shamrock_1982]

I'm celine crazy and im straight.....alot of people think celine male fans are gay i think its funny.....

[GoldenLeaf]

Ire23, on Dec 23 2006, 01:44 PM, said:

I'm celine crazy and im straight.....alot of people think celine male fans are gay i think its funny.....

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Yeah! It's really funny  

[Kerry Elizabeth]

doomqueen, on Dec 22 2006, 05:33 PM, said:

David & Goliath, on Dec 22 2006, 02:28 AM, said:

Céline Dion's fans are not gays, they are bisexual ! l0l

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I think bisexual are trendy ppl, they trying to copy gay ppl too to be cool  

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

Say what??

[Lawna]

Love, on ,Dec 22 2006, 12:13 AM, said:

Someone had to dig this thread back up!

<{POST_SNAPBACK}>

I was thinking the same thing!

But any who, here is my two cents again...

Doesn't really matter, I don't think we come here to judge or label fans, or to judge or label Celine for that matter.

I mean, in all honesty it is interesting to know about other fans and about who they are and what they do, if they would like to share that information, that helps in getting to know each other and networking. But it's not what is important.

[Love,]

Let me set this straight... (no pun intended )

Yes, this topic is like roadkill that has been run over by a freeway of endless cars... yet it has come to the attention and observation of many people here for ages.

I want to let everyone know that: NO ONE KNOWS if the word "most" applies to the number of male Celine fans who are gay.

Let me repeat: NO ONE.

Just because the forum users may give support to such a hypothesis, this forum is NOT a microcosm of the world.

Being a fan does not mean you would have to be a member of any organized community, club, group, daily devotions, etc. I know many straight male Celine fans, in real life, who thinks that being a member of a Celine forum is a bit... much. Nonetheless, they still consider themselves as admirers, because they buy her albums and attend her concerts when she comes around. Even a person who doesn't own any albums or singles or records of Celine's but has a favorite Celine song would be considered a fan, an admirer. Kapish?

I know this won't stop people in the future from making this claim of "most male Celine fans are gay"... but at least I've tried by letting you know what I think.

Ciao  


Now... your thoughts...

Edited by Love,, 21 October 2008 - 03:55 AM.

[Davey84]

your point being?

[Céline's Blues]

Sein Dione sucks anyway.

M 4ever. <3

[Krys]

Love,, on Oct 21 2008, 05:55 PM, said:

Yes, this topic is like roadkill that has been run over by a freeway of endless cars... yet it has come to the attention and observation of many people here for ages.

you got that right. just that i dont see why should there be this thread...do you see a lot of people in the Discussions stereotyping others? no.

[Macaronie]

Davey84, on Oct 21 2008, 10:32 AM, said:

your point being?

That he wants to start a gay club for Céline fans only.

[Snowhite]

Macaronie, on Oct 21 2008, 03:55 PM, said:

Davey84, on Oct 21 2008, 10:32 AM, said:

your point being?

That he wants to start a gay club for Céline fans only.

don't make things worst

[Hilda]

i do actually get yr point! everyone on here seems to be obsessed by that but the truth is that (in my opinion) on here....most of the guy celine fans are gay just coz its a bit of  younger crowed - most straight fans are a bit older id say and probably wouldnt even think of coming somewhere like her to discuss things....and lets face it....discussing divas is such a gay thing to do haha.

Edited by Hilda, 21 October 2008 - 09:49 AM.

[dj4celine]

I don't get your point either, Sopha

lamourpourCeline, on Oct 21 2008, 05:36 PM, said:

Love,, on Oct 21 2008, 05:55 PM, said:

Yes, this topic is like roadkill that has been run over by a freeway of endless cars... yet it has come to the attention and observation of many people here for ages.

you got that right. just that i dont see why should there be this thread...do you see a lot of people in the Discussions stereotyping others? no.

Krys is somewhat right in saying that not many people are stereotyping others (thanks to the broad minded Admins and Mods) but there have been instances where some have been trying to declare their sexual orientation with a I'm-saying-it-on-your-face-that-I'm-not-gay attitude towards others sexual preferences. I maybe be biased on this but I still don't understand why people (in this era) still continue to stereotype people based on their music preferences and be prejudiced towards others.


Anyway, what was your point again, Sopha?

[Annalicious]

It's not just liking Celine...if someone likes Celine AND carries a purse AND has extremely good fashion sense AND says things that sound like they would be said by someone of the gay persuasion then you can't blame people for thinking that person might not be as straight as an arrow.

[Nmj]

Thanks Sopohan ... That relates to me ...I'm with my highschool sweet heart right now.... i have been with her for a long time now and I'm so happy but I'm a huge Celine Dion fan and proud of it...Not that there is anything wrong about being Gay... I just dont like the sterotype that if you are male you are automatically Gay ...That's just wrong and ignorant.
-Nmj

[Scramasboy]

Though I definantly do understand your point, and I am not one to lump a bunch of people in to one group or stereotype, this isn't a new thing and it didn't appear out of thin air. She does have alot of gay fans. I personally don't know any devout straight male Celine fans, but that doesen't mean that all of us male Celine fans are gay and it also doesen't mean the gay to straight ratio is 95/5 or 50/50. There are Celine fans of every race, sex, sexuality, language, ect.

[Scramasboy]

Nmj, on Oct 21 2008, 01:35 PM, said:

Thanks Sopohan ... That relates to me ...I'm with my highschool sweet heart right now.... i have been with her for a long time now and I'm so happy but I'm a huge Celine Dion fan and proud of it...Not that there is anything wrong about being Gay... I just dont like the sterotype that if you are male you are automatically Gay ...That's just wrong and ignorant.
-Nmj

I really admire that! Congrats!

And I agree. Being a male Celine fan doesen't mean your gay.

[Love,]

P.S. This is just a discussion topic, folks. Don't take it too personally. LOL  

Scramasboy, on Oct 21 2008, 01:51 PM, said:

Though I definantly do understand your point, and I am not one to lump a bunch of people in to one group or stereotype, this isn't a new thing and it didn't appear out of thin air. She does have alot of gay fans. I personally don't know any devout straight male Celine fans, but that doesen't mean that all of us male Celine fans are gay and it also doesen't mean the gay to straight ratio is 95/5 or 50/50. There are Celine fans of every race, sex, sexuality, language, ect.

THAT'S THE POINT.

NO ONE knows the ratio.

Nmj, on Oct 21 2008, 01:35 PM, said:

Thanks Sopohan ... That relates to me ...I'm with my highschool sweet heart right now.... i have been with her for a long time now and I'm so happy but I'm a huge Celine Dion fan and proud of it...Not that there is anything wrong about being Gay... I just dont like the sterotype that if you are male you are automatically Gay ...That's just wrong and ignorant.
-Nmj

Well, there can be people who are just wrong, smart aleck and stupid at the same time too.

Edited by Love,, 21 October 2008 - 03:07 PM.

[Davey84]

u still didn't state your point

were is Oscar when you need him?

Edited by Davey84, 21 October 2008 - 03:27 PM.