celine dion vs lara fabian

[celinelover50]

just found this on you tube

 

lara fabian singing PQTME live. its in her own style. i think its rather good and fresh

but noo power and emotion in it like there is in celines but i love them both. but celine wins as aways with me!

was just wondering what people thought!

 

oh here is the link for laras version

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iqAMNdZdkgI...ted&search=

 

here is a link for a celine one

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6rWnRnwT5J8...ted&search=

this has subs on it lol

[nano]

hmm..didn't we have a topic about this.

 

edit: oh, my bad. There isn't a poll or anything about this..

PQTME by Lara was only mentioned here.

 

btw..I love Lara's version, it's different. But no matter how good she is, she will never beat mah dahlin'.

Edited April 24, 2007 at 12:18 PM by nano

[Shaun]

You're seriously asking this on a Celine Dion fan forum?

[celinesounds]

Celine

[JP]

I can't believe this is happening again..

Do the Madonna fans compare it with Kylie? I don't think so because everybody knows they have both good stuff..

 

BTW i will see Lara Fabian live friday this week so i'm the proof we can love both.. But, i'm confirm you we can compare my love for Celine with Lara lol

[WendyB]

Errrrrmmm .................

 

Celine!

[celinelover50]

lol yeah i know its a daft question on here but id like to know peoples opinions......

see i like the difference in laras version but adore the power and emotion of celines!

 

 

WHEN! have madonna or kylie sang each others songs?

Edited April 24, 2007 at 12:25 PM by celinelover50

[Loup_garou]

ewwwwww just hideous

 

Celine All The Way

[DianaLuts]

Celine of course!

[mikymika]

Céline evidemment

[celinelover50]

AH well now someone has voted for laras version!

i hope that werent done out of pity....!lol

 

i hope who ever voted for lara will write in this topic why they went for or preferred laras version!

Edited April 24, 2007 at 02:12 PM by celinelover50

[Teodora]

You're seriously asking this on a Celine Dion fan forum?

That's what I wanted to say Polls of this type are so silly

Anyway... Lara's version is nice too. It's an amazing song, anyone can sing it and it would still sound good.

[celinelover50]

well you havent heard me sing it!

[Davey84]

well of course Céline is the queen of this song!!!! but I like Lara's version too! It's completely different, but that was her goal!

 

BTW i will see Lara Fabian live friday this week so i'm the proof we can love both.. But, i'm confirm you we can compare my love for Celine with Lara lol

 

 

Oh cool JP!! is it the Un regard 9 tour... or is it something else??

[manilou]

This is without a doubt the stupidest survey EVER.

[LaFeeRailleuse]

No doubt for me : CELINE!

This song is so great! To me, one of her best! So nobody can sing it better than her in my opinion...

[Zsuzsa]

I voted for Céline but both of them sing it perfectly. It's a beautiful song and just because I'm a Celine fan, I won't say Lara's is bad but I prefer Celine's version. one of the few songs (like le blues du businessman) she sings with all of her heart every time. Edited April 24, 2007 at 05:51 PM by Zsuzsa

[KimboCosmo]

OMG...I love Lara Fabian! The first time I ever saw her or heard of her was on a awards show singing Adagio. I thought she was ALOT like Celine. I was wondering, does she sing alot of English songs? I can only find like 3. Not finding to many...I wish she would. I'd totally buy her albums.

[SarahJB5]

I voted for Celine's version...I like Lara, but she just doesn't do PQTME any justice at all! She sings it and then speaks some of the words which I thought it was really strange...nobody can every beat Celine at her own songs!!!

[smw]

Is this for real?

[celinelover50]

OMG...I love Lara Fabian! The first time I ever saw her or heard of her was on a awards show singing Adagio. I thought she was ALOT like Celine. I was wondering, does she sing alot of English songs? I can only find like 3. Not finding to many...I wish she would. I'd totally buy her albums.

 

 

lara has two english albums out...im saying that as you say you can only find 3 songs!

[cesardario_colombia]

OMG, Lara's version is amazing! I love that version so much. And Lara Fabians sings like Celine! (i mean in sound), but of course, Celine isthe best Diva ever.

That link of Celine's PQTMAE... well she didnt sing it very well... but still she is amazing

[celinelover50]

well i personally am not finding this topic/poll stupid like some of you are.....look at other people sopinions! im enjoying seeing peoples reaction to this! oh and now everything has a vote...someone even has voted they dont like either! which im totally shocked at!!!!!!

and the last person has just said that laras version is amazing and i agree with that! but still not better than celine!

[pepillo90]

For sure Celine, but I love the Lara's version too

[A New Day Has Come]

I voted for Celine Because no one can sing a Celine song like she does and no one will compare to hers inging But I didn't like laura's at all.

[marckvls]

I just hated Lara's version! She changed everything in the ritm , and it got terrible, like other covers from her

[GoldenLeaf]

Celine version of course!!! Lara Fabian just did a shitty job with that song

[JP]

WHEN! have madonna or kylie sang each others songs?

Yes, Kylie sang Vogue in her last tour (Showgirl Homecoming Tour) and she also have pants with Madonna's face for the last part of the show!

But Madonna never sing a song of Kylie but i don't think it's because she didn't like her, her covers are just pretty rare.

[GoldenLeaf]

WHEN! have madonna or kylie sang each others songs?

Yes, Kylie sang Vogue in her last tour (Showgirl Homecoming Tour) and she also have pants with Madonna's face for the last part of the show!

But Madonna never sing a song of Kylie but i don't think it's because she didn't like her, her covers are just pretty rare.

If I'm not wrong, I guess Kylie also sang Burning Up (Madonna's song)

Edited April 25, 2007 at 12:11 AM by Calypso

[Bellamy]

Waiting for Siur to answer this question.